We had a discussion about domains that need to set both PSD=Y and PSD=N. It highlighted one of the problems with using a tag which implies mutual exclusivity when exclusivity does not apply.
The stated solution was that when PSD=Y is found on the same-domain policy, then PSD=N is also assumed, which implies that strict alignment is also applied. This seemed like a reasonable solution. However, I cannot find any reference to this principle in the specification. What happened? Aside: I will note that this requirement imposes a restriction on private registries if: - the private registry is more than a single label, so that its PSO-registered domain is above the domain used for private registration domain used for clients, and - the private registration domain is used to send mail, and - relaxed alignment is desired between the private registration domain and other domains within the private registrar's organization. I do not see this restriction as unreasonable, but it should be documented. Doug
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dmarc
