On 28/06/2026 19:49, John R Levine wrote:
We know that pct= values other than 0 and 100 never really worked,


At the time, some participants who had actually tried intermediate values reported different experiences.


and pct=0 only made a difference for people who send mail through
mailing lists and other forwarders that edit the message, which is
an extremely small fraction of all mail.  (Someone at Yahoo told me
that for all of the grousing about them turning on p=reject, it
affected about 1% of the mail they got, albeit a 1% that the
recipients felt strongly about.)

And this brings us nicely back to the main topic, since that 1% is precisely the traffic for which ARC was devised. Is it bound to be rounded away or to be properly dealt with? As for Trent's draft, some have objected that it appears to surmise that DKIM2 will solve the mailing-list problem, even though it doesn't address the real reasons why mailing list need to munge From:. That discussion seems to have stalled, and the draft has not been updated.


Best
Ale
--



_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to