I waited until the last minute to respond because I wanted to see as many responses as possible before sharing my thoughts. I am personally agnostic as to with regard to ARC.and its utility Having said that I do not see a consensus that ARC should be marked historic (at this time). Apologies for top posting.
1) I see a number of people have asserted they find it useful. 2) I have seen (unrefuted) assertions that the metrics in the original document for determining success or failure have not been followed in claiming failure. 3) One of the key assertions for marking ARC historic is premised on DKIM2 replacing it's functionality. To me this is a specious argument. DKIM2 is itself experimental and thus far is only partially baked. It has not been deployed and tested in the wild. It is thus at best promiseware. I see no particular need for this working group to rush to adopt Trents document and mark ARC historic. I see 2 reasonable alternative options: 1) Shut the group down and leave ARC status as-is. Let the supporters of ARC continue their experiment and come back at a later point with an updated document and data. 2) Shut the group down and leave ARC status as-is until DKIM2 has time in the wild and it is shown that it's functionality does in fact replace ARC. That would be a more appropriate time to consider marking ARC historic. Michael Hammer On Fri, Jul 3, 2026 at 10:29 AM Barry Leiba <[email protected]> wrote: > OK, this discussion has gone for a while and I don't see new things > coming up. I'd like to take a particular approach now to see where we > are and where we're likely to go. In particular, for right now I do > not want to look at the "dmarc-arc-to-historic" document in > particular, but instead to just focus on the idea of making ARC > "Historic" -- should we do it or not? > > So, first: > If you DO NOT think we should make ARC "Historic", please reply to > this message and tell us, *as concisely as you can* why you think we > should not do that. I'm really not looking for long explanations > here, so please try to keep it tight and clear. If, when you reply, > you've already seen a reply that says what you want to say... then > it's good to just say "I agree with what Ferd said." Apart from that, > please... no comments on what people say here yet. I want to get the > arguments clear first. > > Please do this before the start of the Vienna Hackathon... so, by the > end of everyone's day on Friday, 17 July, two weeks from today. > > (I'm not going to forbid other discussions at this point, but don't > make me do it. It would be best, to avoid distractions and > temptations, if we kept the DMARC mailing list for this purpose for > now.) > > Thanks, > Barry, as chair > > _______________________________________________ > dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] >
_______________________________________________ dmarc mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
