Hi all,

On Mon 20/Jul/2026 14:24:20 +0200 Brotman, Alex wrote:
[...] points that the proposed document mentions in 3.1.
Should we examine each of those bullets for accuracy?  Have we sufficiently 
addressed that section?


The first bullet in Section 3.1 says:

   *  Data-center and intra-domain utility: Early effective use of ARC
      occurred inside single administrative domains or tightly
      controlled data centers, where messages traversed multiple
      internal hops.  Operators applied ARC to ensure messages were not
      modified unexpectedly between their own servers.  In these cases,
      operators already had implicit trust and operational control.

This concept already appears in RFC 8617:

 7.1.2.  Multi-tier MTA Processing

    A large message-processing infrastructure is often divided into
    several processing tiers that can break authentication information
    between tiers.  For example, a large site may maintain a cluster of
    MTAs dedicated to connection handling and enforcement of IP-based
    reputation filtering.  A secondary cluster of MTAs may be dedicated
    and optimized for content-based processing of messages.

    Authenticated Received Chains can be used to communicate
    authentication assessment between processing tiers.

I have difficulty understanding this use case, and I'd ask three questions:

1) Why does a large infrastructure need to authenticate its Authentication-Results? Cryptographic signatures are normally used to protect against malicious tampering. However, in many cases where the same ADMD adds multiple ARC sets, they are all signed with the same key. Sharing that key allows any operator to alter data at will. What threat are the signatures intended to address?

2) If the participating MTAs belong to the same ADMD, what benefit is expected from having intermediate MTAs emit their own ARC sets? Since, as I understand it, only the last valid ARC set can be relied upon, wouldn't it be preferable for the final MTA to emit a single ARC set containing the ADMD's complete authentication assessment?

3) According to Section 4.1.1. of RFC 8617, the AAR MUST contain the combined authres-payload with all of the authentication results from within the participating ADMD. In some cases of multiple ARC sets, all AARs contain the same data (including remote IP address). In other cases, each MTA carries out and reports its own checks as if it were a different ADMD, despite using the same d=. Which behavior is consistent with the specification?


Best
Ale
--









_______________________________________________
dmarc mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to