> On 23 Jan 2020, at 14:11, S Moonesamy <[email protected]> wrote: > > Dear Sara, > At 05:15 AM 23-01-2020, Sara Dickinson wrote: >> > Section 3.2 discusses what a user does and use a DNS query related to >> > email as an example. Is the MUA expected to validated the MX RR or is it >> > the role of the MSA? >> >> I think questions of validation are out of scope for this draft. > > Apologies for not explaining this correctly. The draft is described as a > document about the use of DNS. Section 3.2 has the following: "It gives > information about what the user does ("What are the MX records of > example.net?" means he probably wants to send email to someone at example.net > ..." My question was about that DNS query. Could you or the WG Chairs > please explain why the question which I asked is out of scope for this draft?
Thanks to Brian for his explanation on this point which I agree with. > >> Looking back, this text was introduced into the original I-D before RFC7624 >> was published and wasn't updated. Suggest: >> >> OLD: The IAB privacy and security program also have a work in progress >> [RFC7624] that considers such inference-based attacks in a more general >> framework. >> >> OLD: The IAB privacy and security program has also produced [RFC7624] that >> considers such inference-based attacks in a more general framework." > > I gather that you meant "NEW" for the second part. I am okay with that text. Yes :-) > >> The text says "to our knowledge"; no DPRIVE or IETF review comment to date >> (or errata to RFC7626) has contradicted this statement so I think it is a >> fair representation of the community knowledge on this matter. If you are >> aware of such a law please suggest text. > > I asked whether there was a study. According to the above, it is what the > DPRIVE Working Group believes even though there wasn't any study. I would > like to thank you for the response as it addresses my question. Ah, you were asking if there was a specific citation that could be included… No, not to my knowledge. Thanks for your response. Sara. _______________________________________________ dns-privacy mailing list [email protected] https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dns-privacy
