Brad;

> >  I obviously cannot speak for other major ISPs, and am speaking here as an
> >  individual, not as a representative of AS2548, but I do not see anything
> >  obviously stopping various national carriers from anycasting the root, other
> >  than a) lack of obvious contacts at the roots, and b) lack of perceived
> >  authority. [0] [1]
> 
>       I don't trust them to do the job right.

That's why every ISP should run anycast root servers by itself
not relying on ones run by adjacent ISPs.

> I know a guy at AOL that I'd trust to do the 
> nameservice side correctly, but I'm not sure I'd trust the networking 
> guys to avoid screwing things up.

You are saying that, even if you securely retreive some address
from DNS, you do not trust the networking guys connect you to
a host of the address.

Then, there is no point of secure DNS.

>       Then there's the issue of current DNS UDP truncation at the 
> roots.  There's no way this would fit into ~500 bytes:

Sounds like you never took a look at "anycast".

With UDP without truncation, we can run millions of root servers.

                                                        Masataka Ohta
#----------------------------------------------------------------------
# To unsubscribe, send a message to <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>.

Reply via email to