kre;

>   | Your assumption that source address of a incoming packet is reachable is
>   | improper.
> 
> The source is more likely reachable than some DNS server at some unknown
> location

There are multiple DNS servers. Moreover, you must, anyway, rely on
DNS for forward lookup.

> - at least we know the source address is actually alive and connected
> at the time.

Source host is, source address of the host may not.

> Personally, I have lost essentially all faith in the usefulness of addr->name
> translations at all, and wouldn't mind simply saying "cannot be done" (in
> general of course, it might sometimes work, just don't depend upon it).  But
> if it must be done, the node info query way is good enough.

The primary benefit of having a reverse tree is that the tree makes
address assignement unique.

>   | Never assume routing symmetric.
> 
> What does that have to do with anything?

v6 people including itojun persistently assume it, for example, for
such topics as a source address selection.

                                                        Masataka Ohta
#----------------------------------------------------------------------
# To unsubscribe, send a message to <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>.

Reply via email to