On 11 Jul 2016, at 7:50, Bob Harold wrote:
5.1. Query Format
What if the key tag is less than 0x1000 hex or 4096 decimal - Should
the
resulting hex have leading zeros (always 4 characters?) or not?
For example, would 4095 decimal be _ta-0fff or _ta-fff ? (I prefer
always
4 characters hex, but it is your doc.)
It is a WG doc, not our doc. Do others have a preference on this?
5.3.1. Interaction With Aggressive Negative Caching
I would prefer that the tags always be sorted. No big deal for two
tags,
but if there was a compromise or mistake during a rollover, there
might be
three keys and the savings in records might be significant. If you
decide
to specify sorting, I think it would go in section 5.1 and not in
5.3.1.
Would the "savings in records" really be significant? The problems
caused by people not consistently sorting could make things worse, not
better. Related: there might be other reasons for three tags, such as
during an algorithm rollover.
--Paul Hoffman
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list
[email protected]
https://www.ietf.org/mailman/listinfo/dnsop
