> What's intended behavior of CD=1 client query together with NS
> revalidation? What's intended behavior when CD=1 and CD=0 queries
> hit the same cache?

I'd say that CD covers the Answer and Authority sections of the reply
that goes to the client. With CD=0, those sections cannot have DNSSEC
Bogus RRsets (or violate DNSSEC validation in other ways). With CD=1
those checks are disabled. In my opinion, CD does not affect recursion
because recursion is part of the resolver and does not show up in the
reply that goes to the client.

For example, suppose a domain has a collection of nameserver and all
nameservers are in domains that are DNSSEC bogus. In that case I expect
SERVFAIL even when CD=1.

I don't think the DNS protocol deals with how data is cached (other than
giving a hint how long data can be cached). Caching strategies vary
wildly from one implementation to the next.
_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to