Jim, A few comments inline.
Bob > On Nov 2, 2026, at 3:05 AM, Jim Reid <[email protected]> wrote: > > Here's the draft charter for the proposed WG which will focus on DNS protocol > maintenance and update, leaving dnsop to do DNS Operations. If/when there's > consensus on the proposed charter, the dnsop charter will need to be updated. > Which should be a no-brainer: just delete the 2 paragraphs that mention DNS > protocol maintenance. Nice to see a short charter! > > The name-to-be-decided WG is responsible for maintenance, updates and > extensions to the DNS protocol. This includes defining, updating and > deprecating DNS protocol elements, their wire formats and their processing > rules. The WG is also responsible for documenting and updating the DNS > architecture. Documenting and updating the DNS architecture could be a never ending job. Maybe this wants to have a more limited scope. I don’t see any milestones for this. Reaching consensus on architectural documents in the IETF has a high failure rate. > > DNS operations are out of scope for the name-to-be-decided WG. > > The IESG will decide whenever some aspects of DNS protocol activities are > best carried out in other WGs. When this happens, those topics will be out of > scope for the name-to-be-decided WG. Strongly suggest this be left to the relevant ADs and w.g. chairs. Not everything needs a full IESG decision. > > The name-to-be-decided WG will engage with relevant WGs and other appropriate > organisations especially for WG adoption and Last Calls. It will instruct > IANA whenever changes are needed to its DNS-related registries. Who are "other appropriate organizations” mean? Citing some examples would be good. > > Milestones > > * March 2027: Submit “Signalling a Zone Cut to Nowhere in the DNS” to the > IESG. > > _______________________________________________ > Int-area mailing list -- [email protected] > To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected] _______________________________________________ DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected] To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]
