On Tue Nov 17, 2026 at 6:26 AM CET, Paul Wouters wrote:
No this is incorrect. Think of it this way. It sends the part of the chain
that builds on top of the chain the requester already indicated it knows,
and extends it. If it doesn't fit, the requester now has a longer verified
chain (even if incomplete) but it can on the 2nd query extend its known
trust trust path.

Yes, I think I understood that part - what part of the chain it sends. What I was confused about is the exact value in the CHAIN option in the response.


The requester is basically indicating what DNSSEC records from the root
down it already has, that does not need to be included in the CHAIN.

I agree that "top" here is confusing, but think of it as "top level
domain", as in towards the root.

So lets say you are asking for www.basement.toronto.nohats.ca. (and all
dots are zone cuts with DS records), and you already have the DS for ca in
your cache, then you signal passing "ca" as trust point, so the chain
starts at the DS for nohats.ca. If the entre chain doesn't fit, you build
it from this DS further down. So you try to see if the DS of
toronto.nohats.ca. fits, and if so, you then try to see if the DS for
basement.toronto.nohats.ca. fits. Let's say this doesn't  fit, so you stop
adding to the chain. . Now the requester can ask the exact same question as
before, but sends the trustpoint as "toronto.nohats.ca". Now the chain
starts lower and you could fit the DS for basement.toronto.nohats.ca.

Yes, this makes sense. And I should have probably better explained the issue initially. The current description doesn't really prevent the requester from figuring out the next CHAIN request part, because it can be figured out from provided data (DS records).

Could you include CHAIN option values for both requester and responder in this above example, just to clear this up?

My understanding would be (and this is not in line with example 8.1.):

1) requester: ca
  responder: toronto.nohats.ca (the last one that fit)

2) requester: toronto.nohats.ca
  responder: basement.toronto.nohats.ca

Kind regards,
--
Ensar Sarajčić
w: www.ensarsarajcic.com

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to