Hi Dave,

Thank you for the support. Sorry, I meant Appendix A of our draft
(Alternatives Considered), and not RFC 7871.

BR,
Babak

Dave Lawrence <[email protected]> writes:

> Babak Farrokhi writes:
>> We understand that ECS is a controversial topic. RFC 7871 says in
>> its abstract: "Since it has some known operational and privacy
>> shortcomings, a revision will be worked through the IETF for
>> improvement." Ten years later, we would like to introduce an opt-in
>> option.
>
> Yeah, about that.  Back when I was documenting the existing system
> that Google and OpenDNS had worked out, I was struck by a number of
> ways that it could be better engineered.  I still think that, but my
> departure from Akamai meant it would have just become a free-time
> investment in improving the design of something without even a
> sufficient indication that the installed base would care enough to
> adopt a v2.
>
> That said, I can't recall that an opt-in signal was on my list, but I
> support it and working group adoption.
>
>> The intended status is Experimental.  We use a new option because
>> the signal does not fit inside the ECS option without conflicting
>> with RFC 7871 Appendix A.
>
> I have no qualm with a new option, but don't understand the reference
> to Appendix A.  There are no appendices.

-- 
Babak Farrokhi

Attachment: signature.asc
Description: PGP signature

_______________________________________________
DNSOP mailing list -- [email protected]
To unsubscribe send an email to [email protected]

Reply via email to