Hi Colin,
You can propose this for consideration by the DocBook Technical Committee by 
filing a request on the DocBook SourceForge site.  Use Tracker->RFEs and then 
Submit New.  That's the way to get it in the queue.

Bob Stayton
Sagehill Enterprises
DocBook Consulting
[EMAIL PROTECTED]


  ----- Original Message ----- 
  From: Colin Shapiro 
  To: docbook 
  Cc: [email protected] 
  Sent: Tuesday, July 24, 2007 8:19 AM
  Subject: Re: [docbook] Element for an author's website URL


  [Note: I accidentally CCed the wrong list with the below message.  
docbook-apps, feel free to ignore.]

  "The link is a general purpose hypertext element."

  The element I propose has nothing to do with hypertext.  It is simply another 
part of an <address>, same as <email>, <phone>, etc.  It is another bit of 
information about how to contact a person/organization. 

  If we already have <email>, then why not <web> or <homepage>?  Also remember 
that an email address can be displayed as hypertext as well (i.e. a mailto: 
link in a web browser), but it doesn't have to be.  Same with a home page URL.  
We don't have to use <link> for an email address within <address>. 

  Colin


  On 7/24/07, [EMAIL PROTECTED] <[EMAIL PROTECTED] > wrote:
    Hi,

    > [...]
    > > Maybe I am missing something obvious, but why not use link? 
    >
    > Because it's a link, not a URL

    But a link can also be a URI/URL. According to the TDG[1]:

      »The link is a general purpose hypertext element. [...]
       If it has an xlink:href attribute, link is the equivalent of an 
       HTML anchor (<html:a href="...">) for cross reference
       with a Uniform Resource Identifier (URI).«

    Maybe I didn't understand your argument. But why introduce
    another element when there is already a general purpose element 
    for this issue? :-)


    Bye,
    Tom

    ------
    [1] http://www.docbook.org/tdg5/en/html/link.html




Reply via email to