Timo Sirainen wrote:
On Mon, 2010-11-22 at 12:22 -0700, Willie Gillespie wrote:
Two things I noticed though:
SUBSCRIBE-ing to the mailbox is still successful
Hmm. I kind of disagree with the RFC there.. If you have 'r' rights to
the mailbox, you can select it. You know that it exists then. Why
couldn't you be able to subscribe to it? It even makes sense to me that
if there are mailboxes that +r-l that user should be able to subscribe
to them to make it easier to access them.
Makes sense. And it's strange because the RFC states that SUBSCRIBE and
LSUB only require rights "if the server checks for mailbox existence
when performing SUBSCRIBE." (page 14 of RFC 4314)
So the fact that you can SUBSCRIBE/LSUB to mailboxes without the lookup
ACL isn't too far off anyway.
LSUB will list mailboxes which I do not have lookup rights to
This is intentional. If you have ever subscribed to a mailbox, it's in
your subscriptions list and it won't go away until UNSUBSCRIBE. It
doesn't matter if the mailbox is deleted or its ACLs change.
But, yes, I should restrict the SUBSCRIBE more. Currently it's possible
to subscribe as long as there is any rights to the mailbox. (But if
there are no rights, it's not possible to subscribe, so I don't really
consider this a security hole.) I should probably change it to "l" or
"r". I'll anyway ask what other IMAP people think about this.
I actually ran into this originally with an unusual setup: We wanted a
public namespace which handled it's own subscriptions... but then we
wanted to restrict the namespace to a subset of users. ACLs restricted
this properly for the most part, but LSUB still listed all the mailboxes
to everyone regardless of whether or not they had any rights.
So that didn't work for us. =) Not a big deal, we have other ways we
can make things work for our situation. If somehow LSUB filtered out
mailboxes for which it had no rights to, it would fix that unique
problem though.
Is there a better way to provide a set of mailboxes to a subset of users
with a shared subscription list (subscriptions = yes)?
