I am looking into what it would take to convert our jspui interface into a 
manakin instance.  Way back ( perhaps about 5 years ago ), we took the jspui 
interface and made it our own.  In doing this we moved things around, for 
example, we have the browsing choices that normally appear on the left of the 
page show up on the header, and also the search box.  I was just looking at how 
I would go about doing this in the xmlui world and my guess is that I'd have to 
change the aspect code to generate new more granular XML of the stuff that 
appears on the left, which I think presently is clumped-up together as 
"options", this way I can put the browsing stuff close to the logo and the 
searching stuff towards the right of the header.  Then I have to change the 
theme code to handle this new DRI.  Take a look at what we have now:

http://deepblue.lib.umich.edu/

I believe that in the jspui interface this is easier to change than in the 
xmlui interface because you just need to edit the header jsp file to include 
this and remove it from the jsp file that displays it on the left.  I can see 
that if you are interested in keeping the location of elements as they are in 
the xmlui display why perhaps xmlui would be a better interface, but what about 
when you are trying to move elements around as I am, it seems like then you 
have a lot more code to modify than you would in the jspui interface.

The reason we are thinking of moving over to xmlui are the following:

1.  We have a need to have certain collections in our instance that look very 
different from others, and xmlui facilitates this. In jspui I'd have to add 
some hardcoded exception code, which could get a bit messy, but after looking 
at what I need to do to the xmlui interface, I think it would be less 
complicated.

2.  Dspace is moving away from jspui, and therefore we want to make sure we 
don't get stuck using an interface that may become obsolete.  Is this true?

I know that a lot of institutions use the xmlui interface, and I wonder what 
kind of changes to the out-of-the-box manakin themes they've made.  Could 
someone tell me about their experience?  

I've also heard about how much better xmlui is than jspui, and I'm wondering in 
what sense?  What makes you like one more than the other?

Thank you for your thoughts.

Jose

------------------------------------------------------------------------------
All the data continuously generated in your IT infrastructure contains a
definitive record of customers, application performance, security
threats, fraudulent activity and more. Splunk takes this data and makes
sense of it. Business sense. IT sense. Common sense.
http://p.sf.net/sfu/splunk-d2d-oct
_______________________________________________
DSpace-tech mailing list
[email protected]
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/dspace-tech

Reply via email to