Bear with me a moment on this one, gang. I know some of you are also on the CQ-Contest reflector, where I've been involved the last few days (since the end of CQ WW) in a sometimes heated discussion over operating practices on 40 meters.
The crux of the disagreement revolves around the actions of some SSB stations regarding operating below 7020 kHz. Some of these are North American stations (mainly some US big-guns) who announced they were listening at 7012, 7010, 7007, even 7001 kHz; some of these are various DX stations who were transmitting from the same region. Now... I'm not trying to re-argue the situation here. Suffice to say, IMHO this is poor operating practices to try and have an SSB contest effectively control the entire 40 meter band (to say nothing of the long-term effect of ticking off CW ops pushed out of the way and making them anti-contest). I've had several counter-arguments, two amateurs (one US, one VE) in particular. I'm being told things like "the band is crowded so we go where we have to," "if it's not strictly illegal it's allowed," "the contest operators can't impose band limits," "if the contest operators try to limit things that aren't illegal they open themselves up to litigation," "non-contesters should use the WARC bands," "a run frequency is more important that a 5 WPM Extra talking across town," "CW is dying anyway," "band plans are voluntary," and my personal favorites, "it only happens two weekends a year, CQ WW & ARRL DX (what about CQ WPX and IARU and WAE and...) so deal with it," and "CW is being abandonded by administrations around the world so nobody cares." Amongst many others, but you catch the drift. I've also had a small group encourage me -- privately, few in public posts. The vast majority? Silent. So... am I wrong here? Now granted, a big-gun I'm not and probably never will be, especially from the new QTH (I'm just glad the vertical kinda WORKS right now! Well, it's been 3 1/2 years since the last permanent QTH...). My operating time was very limited due to family obligations. But I was just floored by some of the 40 meter "listening" frequencies I saw on the cluster on Saturday night (ET). And I heard a lot of CW activity that got squashed by people calling or responding to a "CQ CONTEST." So, I figured that there'd be some griping about it. But only one person did (my participation started as part of the response), and he quickly got told to go fishing if he didn't like it. Am I off base in finding this situation unpalatable? Am I in the minority, or are most just shrugging and putting up with this because they don't think anything can be done? Subscribe/unsubscribe, feedback, FAQ, problems http://njdxa.org/dx-chat To post a message, DX related items only, email@example.com This is the DX-CHAT reflector sponsored by the NJDXA http://njdxa.org