OK, follow-up after briefly discussing this issue during the dedicated
IRC session of UbuntuOpenWeek ("An introduction to the messaging
indicator" session by Ken Van Dine)

<guillom> QUESTION: the indicator applet now notifies about things that were 
filtered (and hidden) before (e.g. the getting-online notifications from pidgin 
when in silent mode); this looks like a regression, since now one is 
overwhelmed by useless notifications ; is this behaviour a bug, a feature or a 
matter of configuration?.
<kenvandine_wk> yes and no
<kenvandine_wk> for example, if your friend Jorge shows up online, yes it adds 
an indicator for that even so you can quickly IM him if you want to harrass him 
:)
<kenvandine_wk> but
<kenvandine_wk> since jorge didn't IM you, it goes away after some time limit 
without acting on it
<kenvandine_wk> i think it is like 30 seconds, but not sure
[...]
<kenvandine_wk> the indicator is more event based, it doesn't care what creates 
it
[...]
<kenvandine_wk> pidgin tells the indicator when there is an event you should be 
concerned about

It is a regression, since the indicator forces the display of
notifications that the user chose to ignore by enabling the "silent
mode" in Pidgin. But from what I understand of what Ken said, the issue
comes from Pidgin, who doesn't filter the notification before it's sent
to the indicator. So, it rather sounds like a Pidgin bug. If so, can
someone close this one?

-- 
Indicator-applet displays getting-online notifications from Pidgin even if 
Pidgin is in silent mode
https://bugs.launchpad.net/bugs/367865
You received this bug notification because you are a member of Indicator
Applet Developers, which is the registrant for Indicator Applet.

Status in Indicator Applet: New

Bug description:
The "silent" mode in Pidgin used to prevent the "X is now online" notifications 
from popping up when you're busy. Since Jaunty & the new indicator applet, this 
indicator displays all these notifications even if Pidgin is in "silent" mode, 
which completely nullifies this option. Nobody on IRC was able to tell me if 
this was a bug, a feature or a matter of configuration.

Expected behaviour: When Pidgin is in "silent" mode, the indicator applet 
shouldn't display the "X is now online" notifications, it should only display 
the "new chat" notifications.

_______________________________________________
Mailing list: https://launchpad.net/~dx-team
Post to     : [email protected]
Unsubscribe : https://launchpad.net/~dx-team
More help   : https://help.launchpad.net/ListHelp

Reply via email to