Or how a single government bureaucrat (who shouldn't
have this power to begin with, nor any government) 
can hurt his own country.

This wouldn't change the world's *demand* for gold though.

Bob

"Franco/Gold Fields Merger

The South African gold mining industry was blindsided recently with the
announcement that the country's  Minister of Finance declined to approve
the
merger of Gold Fields Limited  with Canadian Franco-Nevada Mining
Corporaton.
The minister cited a violation of the country's exchange control rules. 
Although it is believed that the merger received approval from the South
Afican 
Reserve Bank and other regulatory authorities, including the Securities
Regulation
Panel and the Competitions Board, it failed to receive approval from the
South 
African finace minister Trevour Manuel.

According to Mr. Manuel, an important issue is that there is no benefit
to
South Africa in the merger, which he believes would allow the new
Canadian-
based company to charge large fees to the South African based gold
mines. This
could reduce profits subject to South African taxes. Even before the
minister's 
decision, a study of the South African miniing industry stated that the
future of the
industry depends on continued production from the country's  two primary
gold 
mines, Driefontein and Kloof, both owned by Gold Fields. A reduction of
taxes 
paid from these two industry giants could have a very large effect on
the amount
of taxes paid by the industry.

Gold Fields is seeking a meeting with Mr. Manuel to respond to his
concerns.
Franco-Nevada's chairman Seymour Schulich was said to be upset by the
decision,
stating that the company has no further plans to pursue the merger, but
would be willing to listen to any revised proposal by Gold Fields or the
South
African government. Gold Fields has indicated it's intention to "seek
another 
way of concluding the deal." People close to the situation have
indicated that 
it would be difficult for Franco-Nevada  and Gold Fields to satisfy
South African 
demands to maintain the new company's primary listing in the
Johannesburg 
Stock Exchange and a seconday listing on the Toronto Exchange. This 
is the reverse of the original proposal which was primarily structured
so that 
Canadian shareholders in Franco-Nevada would not be required to pay the 
capital gains tax on their investment. Canadian law also restricts
residents 
holding more than 20 percent of their porfolios offshore, thereby
possibly 
restricting the amount of the new company, known as Gold Fields
International, 
they could hold.

The consensus seems to be that the Franco-Nevada merger with Gold Fields 
is dead. This decision may be premature as the death of this merger may 
forecast the imminent death of the South African gold mining industry.
As 
stated by Harmony Gold's Managing Director Bernard Swanepoel, "South 
African gold companies have about three years to 'make it big' on the
world's 
gold producing stage or be left behind." The merger of Franco and Gold
Fields 
would establish a world class gold mining company which will be
strengthened 
by further growth in its global portfolio as well as providing the
necessary 
capital funds needed to expand and develop the remaining opportunities
in 
South Africa. This political decision, if left to stand, will devastate
South 
Africa's ability to draw new foreign investment into the county."

By American Investment Services Inc. 
(wholly owned by the American Institute for Economic Research)
http://www.aier.org/

---
You are currently subscribed to e-gold-list as: [email protected]
To unsubscribe send a blank email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]

Reply via email to