> Subject: > Advanced Online Banking, Born of Necessity > Date: > Sun, 25 Mar 2001 06:46:57 -0500 > From: > "R. A. Hettinga" <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > To: > Digital Bearer Settlement List <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> > > > http://www.nytimes.com/2001/03/25/technology/25BRAZ.html > > > March 25, 2001 > > Advanced Online Banking, Born of Necessity > > By DAVID LIPSCHULTZ > > ÃO PAULO, Brazil -- Rodrigo Abreu has not been inside a bank here in more > than three years. He has not written a paper check for any regular expense > in nearly that long. For almost half a decade, Mr. Abreu, now 30 and a > technology executive, has made every kind of scheduled payment through the > Internet arm of his bank, Banco Itau. > > He is paying car insurance, buying stocks and conducting e-commerce through > the bank's Web site. His 68-year-old mother and all his other family > members are also doing most of their business transactions online. The same > goes, he said, for "absolutely everyone I know here." > > Advanced Internet technology is not generally associated with Brazil, where > a vast majority of the population of 171.2 million has no online access. > But when it comes to Internet banking, the country is a leader. > > "I definitely would put the major Brazilian banks in the very elite in the > world of online banking," says Virginia Philipp, an analyst at Tower Group, > a research organization based in Needham, Mass., that covers financial > services and technology. "Banks across the world look to them as models." > > It was Brazil's dire economic problems that helped pressure major banks - > Bradesco, Unibanco and Banco Itau - to build advanced electronic payment > systems that formed the backbone of the Internet services they offer today. > > In the early 1990's, Brazil's economy faced such inflationary pressures > that the currency, the real, would sometimes lose 3 percent of its value in > a day. In grocery stores, shoppers heard announcements that the price of > bread had just gone up. To combat the hyperinflation, banks built > communications systems to clear checks and allow their customers to pay > bills as soon as possible. That helped the customers avoid losing money > during processing. > > "We were able to cash checks within 24 hours when the U.S. banks were still > taking nearly a week," said Milton Monteiro, who is vice president and is > in charge of Internet banking at Banco Itau. "We had to be very efficient." > > By 1993, each major Brazilian bank had built a complex private network so > that when a customer's paycheck came in, it was cleared overnight and moved > into an account that was hedged against inflation. Home banking was coming > into vogue and people were already dialing directly into the banks' > networks to move money and pay bills instantly. In the United States, > meanwhile, manual check processing and human bank tellers were still the > norm. > > Y 1996, as the Internet began to take hold, the Brazilian banks not only > had their own networks in place but also had the back-office support to > advance quickly into online banking. > > "In 1998, when U.S. banks were just trying to figure out the Internet, > Brazilian banks were well ahead with a huge range of offerings," Ms. > Philipp said. > > While many United States banks, like Wells Fargo and Bank of America, are > certainly catching up with the range of their online offerings, Bradesco, > Banco Itau and Unibanco still have a wider array of Internet services. > Brazilians can complete basically any type of financial transaction through > the banks' Web sites. Banks offer e- commerce portals, advanced > business-to- business services, brokerage services, direct deposit and > bill-paying, all integrated into their Web sites. > > In fact, under a bill-paying standard now used in Brazil, bank customers > can simply type in the bar code number of any bill; the bank immediately > knows its amount and pays it upon request. > > "When I lived in the U.S., I definitely found myself doing things I had > almost forgotten about, like writing paper checks and going to a physical > bank branch," said Mr. Abreu, who lived alternately in Palo Alto, Calif., > and Brazil from 1998 until last year. > > Brazil's advances in Internet banking, however, do not necessarily reflect > technological backwardness among American banks, which for many years > operated under far more stringent restrictions about the breadth of their > operations. Brazilian banks have long been free to offer both commercial > banking and brokerage services, unfettered by regulations that only > recently were relaxed in the United States with the end of the > Depression-era Glass- Steagall Act. > > "Because of Glass-Steagall, we've definitely had to go slower," said Dan > Hilken, senior vice president for investments at Wells Fargo. > > But the economic crisis was a big factor in prompting Brazil's banks to act > faster than their counterparts in Europe and the United States. > > "We built up Internet banking not because it was fashionable like in the > U.S., but because it created serious value to the customers and thus the > bank," said Candido Leonelli, who is in charge of Internet banking at > Bradesco, Brazil's largest private bank. > > The relatively long history of online banking in Brazil is seen in its > acceptance by customers. Bradesco says that 22 percent of its customers > bank online, while Banco Itau says its figure is 25 percent. That compares > with 15 percent at Wells Fargo, a leader in United States online banking. > > Those numbers alone, however, do not tell the whole story, because only > about 4 percent of people in Brazil even have Internet access, compared > with about 50 percent of people in the United States. That means that among > Internet users, vastly higher percentages of Brazilians are banking online. > > CCESS, however, could be the biggest obstacle in expanding the country's > Internet banking culture. After figuring in the cost of a computer, its > accessories and an Internet service provider, online access can cost more > than $1,500 in Brazil - more than one-third of the $4,200 annual income of > the average Brazilian, the World Bank estimates. So even though analysts > estimate that Internet access in Brazil will triple over the next three > years, the banks will soon encounter a firm ceiling. > > Banks are starting to offer financing for computers and sponsoring free > Internet access in an effort to put more people online. Even so, with 17 > percent of the population making less than $7 a day, it is likely that many > Brazilians will not be able to take advantage of the country's banking > technology. > > "Finding a way to get everyone access," Mr. Leonelli said, "is definitely > one of our biggest challenges." > > > Copyright 2001 The New York Times Company > > -- > ----------------- > R. A. Hettinga <mailto: [EMAIL PROTECTED]> > The Internet Bearer Underwriting Corporation <http://www.ibuc.com/> > 44 Farquhar Street, Boston, MA 02131 USA > "... however it may deserve respect for its usefulness and antiquity, > [predicting the end of the world] has not been found agreeable to > experience." -- Edward Gibbon, 'Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire' > --- You are currently subscribed to e-gold-list as: [email protected] To unsubscribe send a blank email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
