In my two decades of observing the natural world, I have found that the most 
useful identification guidebooks are those in the Peterson series, or which 
follow a format like the Peterson series: text descriptions on the left page, 
line drawings or paintings on the right, with little arrows pointing out 
important details or field marks.  This allows anywhere from 8 to 12 species 
per page, enabling a sufficiently comprehensive treatment in a volume compact 
enough to carry in the field.
 
Unfortunately, the Peterson series has never published a wildflower guide to 
the Southeastern US.  There are wildflower guides in this series for every 
other US region: Northeastern/North-Central; Southweatern/Texas; Great Plains; 
Rocky Mountains; Pacific States.  While there is some overlap in species, there 
are also some species in the Southeast that do not occur in these other regions.
 
In my search for a guide to wildflowers of the Southeast, I have found only two 
kinds of sources: technical floras, which use dichotomous keys and cover all 
angiosperms including trees, and are thus too large and cumbersome to carry in 
the field; and popular wildflower books that use photographs.  The trouble with 
photographs are many: for one thing, only two or three species can be shown per 
page, thus necessitating a less comprehensive coverage.  On any given day in 
the field, I encounter wildflowers not shown in the photographic guidebooks.  
Secondly, photographic guides tend to be biased toward those species with 
easily-seen, conspicuous flowers; you will not find many Chenopodiaceae, for 
example, in photographic guides.  Thirdly, other vegetation in the photograph 
often obscures important details; the most egregious example I have found so 
far is in Batson 1987, _Wildflowers in the Carolinas_, University of South 
Carolina: on p.118, the photo of
 Utricularia.  The Utricularia in the picture is much overshadowed by the showy 
yellow spadices of Orontium, such that it could appear that Orontium was the 
taxon being illustrated.  For these reasons, I find photographic guidebooks 
nearly useless.
 
Given that the Peterson series never published a wildflower guide to the 
Southeastern US, are there any guidebooks to this region which follow a similar 
format, and would thus be useful to me?
 
Jason Hernandez

Reply via email to