Oklahoma Scenic Rivers Joint Phosphorus Criteria Study
Request for Statement of Qualifications

http://www.ok.gov/conservation/Agency_Divisions/Water_Quality_Division/IR_Jo
int_Study_Committee.html

Background:
The Second Statement of Joint Principals and Actions between the states of 
Arkansas and Oklahoma calls for a joint study to determine “the total 
phosphorus threshold response level, in milligrams per liter (mg/L), at 
which any statistically significant shift occurs in algal species 
composition or algal biomass production resulting in undesirable aesthetic 
or water quality conditions in the Designated Scenic Rivers.”  The study 
will be completed in accordance with EPA guidance on quality 
assurance/quality control and following EPA’s “Using Stressor-response 
Relationships to Derive Numeric Nutrient Criteria” (EPA 820-S-10-001), 
November 2010).  These documents and other information pertinent to the 
process are available under the public meetings section at the following 
website:  www.ok.gov/conservation/.

The study shall also include an adequate sampling population to determine 
the frequency and duration component of the numeric criterion.  Should 
reference streams or sites be included in the study, these sites should, to 
the extent possible, be limited to streams and rivers within the 
physiographic region and relatively comparable to the streams in the 
designated Oklahoma Scenic River watersheds in terms of stream order, 
habitat, hydrology and watershed land uses.  This study should also include 
an assessment of local factors, generally habitat and hydrology, which might 
influence algal community structure and growth across the selected rivers.
The study will result in a final report which will provide an objective 
analysis of the water quality data and identify relationships, if any, 
between various concentrations of phosphorus in the Oklahoma designated 
scenic rivers and multiple ecological response levels commonly used in the 
scientific community to describe undesirable aesthetic and water quality 
conditions.  The study will be expected to recommend phosphorus thresholds, 
and what frequency and duration components of measure, which suggest an 
undesirable shift in algal species composition and or biomass.  The 
phosphorus thresholds should be protective of the aesthetics beneficial use 
and scenic river (Outstanding Resource Water) designations assigned to the 
Oklahoma designated Scenic Rivers, and based on overall stream health.

Process:
The Governors of Arkansas and Oklahoma appointed three members each of a 
committee designated to develop and oversee said joint study over a three 
year period.  In addition, the state of Arkansas has devoted a maximum of 
$600,000 toward completion of the study.  Members of this committee have 
selected a process and established a timeline toward that end.  In doing so, 
they are requesting statements of qualifications from experienced 
researchers that meet the criteria listed below.
  
The committee will review submitted statements of qualifications and request 
proposals and interviews from a selected group of the highest ranked 
applicants.  The committee requests qualifications be submitted to Shellie 
Chard-McClary, Water Quality Division Director, Oklahoma Department of 
Environmental Quality; street address 707 N Robinson, Oklahoma City, 73102; 
mailing address P.0. Box 1677, Oklahoma City, OK  73101-1677 or via email to 
[email protected].  Submissions must be date stamped and 
received by December 27, 2013 at 4:30 p.m.

Criteria for Statement of Qualifications:
At a minimum, applicants must exclude organizations and personnel based in 
Arkansas or Oklahoma or in any way engaged in the 2005 lawsuit brought by 
Oklahoma against poultry companies based in Arkansas. Finally, any parties 
which have or have had financial involvement with the six designated 
committee members (Dr. Brian Haggard, Dr. Marty Matlock, and Dr. Thad Scott, 
each from the University of Arkansas, Shellie Chard-McClary, Oklahoma 
Department of Environmental Quality, Shanon Phillips, Oklahoma Conservation 
Commission, and Derek Smithee, Oklahoma Water Resources Board) must declare 
this potential conflict of interest.  

The Statement of qualifications must include:
1. Descriptions of experience with similar projects 
2. Two examples of summary reports for similar projects, or  peer-reviewed 
journal publications
3. Specific qualifications of research team

Timeline for Selection and Study Process:
The Committee will review submitted qualifications in December 2013.  The 
committee will meet on January 6th to rank qualifications and select the top 
three candidates.  Following said meeting, a proposal will be requested from 
the top candidates to be presented to the committee in Tulsa, OK on February 
5, 2014. The contract award winner will be notified of their selection soon 
after that meeting and will work with the committee over the next month to 
finalize the details of the proposal with a final contract to be in place by 
April 2014.  The end date for the study should be December 2016.  The 
selected researchers will be prepared to update the committee on the study 
progress during at least two public meetings to be held during the contract 
date, the first of which has been set for October 9, 201410:00 a.m. in 
Tulsa, OK.

Administrative questions only about the submission process can be directed 
to :   Shellie Chard-McClary at 405-702-8100 or at the above email address.  
Technical questions can be answered by referring to the Second Statement of 
Joint Principals and Actions found on the www.ok.gov/conservation/ website.

Reply via email to