Frequently, the major slowdown is the time it takes for the authors to revise, particularly if the first editorial decision is major revision.
~~~~ +/*\+ ~~~~ Geoffrey M. Henebry PhD CSE Co-Director, Geospatial Sciences Center of Excellence (GSCE) Professor, Natural Resource Management South Dakota State University 1021 Medary Avenue, Wecota Hall 506B Brookings, SD 57007-3510, USA voice: +1-605-688-5351 (-5227 FAX) email: [email protected]<mailto:[email protected]> http://globalmonitoring.sdstate.edu/content/henebry-geoffrey-m From: Ecological Society of America: grants, jobs, news [mailto:[email protected]] On Behalf Of Edwin Cruz-Rivera Sent: Tuesday, April 26, 2016 8:53 AM To: [email protected] Subject: [ECOLOG-L] The speed of peer-review Dear All, I am very curious about the life cycle of manuscripts in online journals these days. I have been doing some numbers on PLOS One, which advertises as the journal "accelerating the publication of peer-reviewed" science. However, a quick look at the papers that have been published in the past few months reveals most of these were accepted 5-9 months after submission. What strikes me as odd is that PLOS One gives you two weeks to review a manuscript, and they start pestering you with reminders even before the review is late...and may you not be late for 48 hours! So how does a journal that expects such a fast turnaround from peer reviewers deal with authors at such glacial pace? To begin with, it is not as if publication comes cheap in this journal. Should 1250 USD not include a bit of expediency? The numbers here seem odd. We have had a paper stuck in limbo since November 2015 without a final answer yet, supposedly because they cannot find an editor (out of > 6000) who can manage the revised version of the paper. So the key question is, I suppose: Is this seemingly epic sluggishness the norm in open access/online publication these days? At this point, I am not really convinced PLOS One should be advertising as "the fast one"...or is it? Any thoughts? Edwin ================= Dr. Edwin Cruz-Rivera Visiting Associate Professor Department of Biological Sciences University of the Virgin Islands #2 John Brewers Bay St. Thomas 00802 USVI Tel: 1-340-693-1235 Fax: 1-340-693-1385 "It is not the same to hear the devil as to see him coming your way" (Puerto Rican proverb)
