Rudi Vankeirsbilck wrote:

>Hi,I have not used TOPLink before but I was planning to do so in the future.
>Thank you for your remarks. I agree that those restrictions are not
>acceptable. This shows that the TOPLink product is not mature enough.

I agree TOPLink does have some limitations, but they are relatively easy to live with. 
And, as has been pointed out before, some of them will disappear with JDK 1.2.

We have evaluated a number of O-R mapping products and concluded that only TOPLink had 
all the features we needed. Flexible mapping strategies to allow mapping to a legacy 
database was one of them. We also found TOPLink was the least intrusive of the tools 
we looked at.

As for maturity: I understand TOPLink Java is based on a TOPLink Smalltalk product 
that had already been used by the Object People for several years. The Java version 
GA'd in spring 1998 if I remember well, we have been using it since then. We _do_ 
think the product is mature enough.

My favourite missing TOPLink feature: to be able to generate a TOPLink mapping layer 
from an XMI file (which in turn can be generated from Rational Rose and other 
modellers). I hope the Object People will jump on the XMI bandwagon soon...

Regards, Luc Peerdeman.

===========================================================================
To unsubscribe, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED] and include in the body
of the message "signoff EJB-INTEREST".  For general help, send email to
[EMAIL PROTECTED] and include in the body of the message "help".

Reply via email to