Le lundi 22 octobre 2007 à 14:19 +0100, Philippe Laliberte a écrit : > Damien Sandras wrote: > > Le lundi 22 octobre 2007 à 11:52 +0100, Philippe Laliberte a écrit : > > > >> ael wrote: > >> > >>> P laliberte wrote: > >>> > >>> > >>>> ael wrote: > >>>> > >>>> > >>>>> Philippe Laliberte wrote: > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>>> Hello, > >>>>>> > >>>>>> I am running into a little problem. I did dig into the wiki but to no > >>>>>> avail. > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Set-up: > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Fedora 7. > >>>>>> kernel-2.6.22.9 > >>>>>> Firewall disabled. selinux disabled > >>>>>> Ekiga 2.0.11 > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Router Modem ADSL SpeedTouch 780 > >>>>>> Firewall disabled (once I get Ekiga working I'll test what I can close) > >>>>>> VoIp turned off > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Modem routing Configuration > >>>>>> > >>>>>> Protocol Port Range Translate To ... Trigger Protocol > >>>>>> Trigger Port Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 > >>>>>> - - > >>>>>> UDP 3479 - 3479 3479 - 3479 > >>>>>> UDP 3479 > >>>>>> UDP 3478 - 3479 3478 - 3479 > >>>>>> UDP 3478 > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>>> > >>>>> I can't quite decode the above. If you trigger on 3478 (UDP) and then > >>>>> open 5000 -5100 (UDP) then it should be ok. I am not sure that is what > >>>>> you have above is it? I can't make out the first line ending in > >>>>> 5000-5100: how does that relate to the two following lines? > >>>>> > >>>>> ael > >>>>> _______________________________________________ > >>>>> ekiga-list mailing list > >>>>> [email protected] > >>>>> http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>>> > >>>> Just missing a cariage return > >>>> > >>>> Protocol Port Range Translate To ... Trigger Protocol Trigger > >>>> Port Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 - - > >>>> UDP 3479 - 3479 3479 - 3479 UDP 3479 > >>>> UDP 3478 - 3479 3478 - 3479 UDP 3478 > >>>> > >>>> > >>>> What you mean is that I should just do : > >>>> > >>>> UDP 5000 - 5100 3479 - 3479 UDP 3479 > >>>> UDP 5100 - 5100 3478 - 3479 UDP 3478 > >>>> > >>>> > >>> Looking at that again, why are you translating 3479 into 5000-5100? Or > >>> am I misunderstanding the web interface (I assume)? > >>> > >>> Once you see a packet on 3478, then open 5000-5100. Do not translate > >>> 3478 into 5000... if that is what the above means. 3478 and 3479 should > >>> be (con) tracked properly by the router. It is just that it will block > >>> 5000-5100 unless it is told otherwise. > >>> > >>> I have not encountered a SpeedTouch router so I may be misunderstanding > >>> its configuration. > >>> > >>> ael > >>> > >>> > >> The error is mine, late doing too many thing at the same time. You did > >> understand it correctly the first time. > >> > >> UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3479 > >> UDP 5100 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3478 > >> I'll test it later this afternoon thanks. > >> > >> > > > > Why 5100 - 5100 ? > > > > > > Well unconclusive: > > UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3479 > UDP 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 UDP 3478 > > > Wizard, still in symetric NAT > > Manual STUN: No sound on [EMAIL PROTECTED], no calls in from Diamoncard even > after a fresh restart > None: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh > restart. > > > Back to no trigger definition, same as above. > > Back to TCP/UDP > > Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 Any 3478 > Any 5000 - 5100 5000 - 5100 Any 3479 > > Wizard, still in symetric NAT > > STUN: No sound on [EMAIL PROTECTED], Calls in from Diamoncard OK even after > a while, after manual changes back and forth it does not work anymore > > None: [EMAIL PROTECTED] ok, no calls in from Diamoncard even after a fresh > restart. > > Back to no trigger definition, same as above. > > Wireshark shows SIP activity for the [EMAIL PROTECTED] call but nothing > coming > in from Diamoncard. > > Can all this working not working be related to a slowness from > diamoncard or the router to react to changes? I am connected to > eugw.ast.diamondcard.us. If I try to setup my VoIp on the modem, it > never seems to register. > > I'll go back to STUN (with trigger of the router) and shutdown Ekiga for > an hour or so to see if when I come back It will work. >
In my opinion, the problem lies in the configuration of your router. There is relatively few that we can do. If it detects symmetric NAT, that is probably because the port forwarding does not work appropriately. -- _ Damien Sandras (o- //\ Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/ v_/_ NOVACOM : http://www.novacom.be/ FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/ SIP Phone : sip:[EMAIL PROTECTED] _______________________________________________ ekiga-list mailing list [email protected] http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
