Hi, Le dimanche 14 décembre 2008 à 20:21 +0100, Bent a écrit : > Hi > > I have been unsubscribed to this list for a while so some > advertisements may have posted regarding my problem. There is, > however, not anything like it in the archives as far as I have been > able to determine. > > Anyway, my problem is stated in the subject line. Here are some details: > > Asterisk runs on my gateway/firewall. My ekiga softphone (which is > 2.0.12 - the latest issued by Gentoo) runs on a workstation behind the > firewall. I use no proxy, but the firewall (another box running Gentoo > Linux) has the SIP ALG enabled. > > Asterisk registers fine with ekiga.net: > > b...@yosie ~ $ tshark -r ekiga-asterisk.trace > Running as user "bent" and group "users". > 1 0.000000 86.48.49.19 -> 86.64.162.35 SIP Request: OPTIONS sip:ekiga.net > 2 0.024013 86.64.162.35 -> 86.48.49.19 SIP Status: 484 Address Incomplete
The Address Incomplete thing has just been fixed. It was a bug in the Kamailio configuration. > 3 0.093378 86.48.49.19 -> 86.64.162.35 SIP Request: REGISTER > sip:ekiga.net > 4 0.116927 86.64.162.35 -> 86.48.49.19 SIP Status: 401 > Unauthorized (0 bindings) > 5 0.117983 86.48.49.19 -> 86.64.162.35 SIP Request: REGISTER > sip:ekiga.net > 6 0.142500 86.64.162.35 -> 86.48.49.19 SIP Status: 200 OK (1 bindings) > b...@yosie ~ $ > > whereas Ekiga the softphone doesn't: > > b...@yosie ~ $ tshark -r ekiga.trace > Running as user "bent" and group "users". > 1 0.000000 86.48.49.19 -> 86.64.162.35 SIP Request: REGISTER > sip:ekiga.net > 2 0.009675 86.48.49.19 -> 86.64.162.35 SIP Request: SUBSCRIBE > sip:[email protected] > 3 0.023790 86.64.162.35 -> 86.48.49.19 SIP Status: 606 Not > Acceptable (0 bindings) > 4 0.033924 86.64.162.35 -> 86.48.49.19 SIP Status: 202 OK > b...@yosie ~ $ Apparently, you are trying to register a private IP. Perhaps you have STUN enabled and the gateway replaces the public IP it sees by a private IP ? > Several questions arise: > > 1. Why do I get '484 Address Incomplete' when my Asterisk asks for options? > > 2. Why does my Ekiga get a '606 Not Acceptable' when it tries to register? See above. > 3. Why is the subscribe accepted '202 OK'? It is how it should be ;-) -- _ Damien Sandras (o- //\ Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/ v_/_ Be IP : http://www.beip.be/ FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/ SIP Phone : sip:[email protected] _______________________________________________ ekiga-list mailing list [email protected] http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
