Hello,
Joseph Comfort wrote:
....
(People use ekiga, and complain, but few help...)
For most of people, like me, are only users but developers. What the best
we can contribute is to feedback our experience. If one thinks in another
way, complain is a good thing. Under what condition there will be no
complain ---- no one is really using it.
Attached is a piece of the ekiga -d 4 output while attempting to connect
to a meeting room at KEK. I hope this can give the experts some clues.
The symptom is different from before. This time I cannot make any
connection. Before at lease I can have "Connected with RADVISION MCU".
physjg
On Sat, 27 Jun 2009, Eugen Dedu wrote:
Joseph Comfort wrote:
Unfortunately, I have not found much in the way of good H323 alternatives
to Ekiga. There are alternatives for SIP. I'm only a user, but it seems
to me that Ekiga has gone too far out on the bleeding edge with all kinds
of frilly add-ons which depend on OS systems and packages (even compilers)
that are still in development. Maintenance of the core functionality is
drowning. I have not yet had a successful compilation of the latest
source. Still, the basic issue may be in the audio stuff of the OS.
I agree with you that the core functionality is the most important, and
it should work flawlessly. The work is focused on this goal currently.
If you look at recent commits, there are only fixes, and many fixes.
It still seems that sometimes, these fixes break other parts of the
software. I suppose this is because SIP/H323 is very complex.
(People use ekiga, and complain, but few help...)
Joe Comfort
On Fri, 26 Jun 2009, Damien Sandras wrote:
Le vendredi 26 juin 2009 à 15:35 +0800, physjg a écrit :
The full output is too long so my previous mail was blocked.
This one is with the "short" version of the ekiga -d 4 output.
There is no call attempt.
However, from Damien Sandras's mail. does it mean Ekiga can be out of
free
H.323 software business now?
It is maintained, but not improved anymore.
--
_ Damien Sandras
(o-
//\ Ekiga Softphone : http://www.ekiga.org/
v_/_ Be IP : http://www.beip.be/
FOSDEM : http://www.fosdem.org/
SIP Phone : sip:[email protected]
_______________________________________________
ekiga-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
------------------------------------------------------------------------
_______________________________________________
ekiga-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
_______________________________________________
ekiga-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
2009/06/28 14:05:53.400 6:11.627 OpalMan Set up
call from pc:* to h323:[email protected]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.401 6:11.628 Call Created
Call[y1b92e0d81]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.401 6:11.628 OpalMan Set up
connection to "pc:*"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.403 6:11.630 OpalCon Created
connection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.403 6:11.630 Silence
Parameters set: mode=AdaptiveSilenceDetection, threshold=0, silencedb=3200,
signaldb=80, period=4800
2009/06/28 14:05:53.403 6:11.630 Silence Handler
created
2009/06/28 14:05:53.404 6:11.631 Echo Canceler
Handler created
2009/06/28 14:05:53.404 6:11.631 PCSS Created
PC sound system connection: token="sf6d465192" player="EKIGA" recorder="EKIGA"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.404 6:11.631 OpalCon
SetPhase from UninitialisedPhase to SetUpPhase for
Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.632 OpalMan
OnIncoming connection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.632 OpalCon
Applying string options:
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.632 Call
GetOtherPartyConnection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.632 OpalMan
Searching for route "pc:physjg h323:[email protected]"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.632 OpalMan Set up
connection to "h323:[email protected]"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.405 6:11.633 H323 Making
call to: h323:[email protected]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.406 6:11.633 DNS SRV
Lookup h323gk.kek.jp service _h323._tcp
2009/06/28 14:05:53.446 6:11.673 OpalCon Created
connection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 RFC2833 Handler
created
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 RFC2833 Handler
created
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 H460
Endpoint Attached
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 H323 Created
new connection: localhost/8175
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 PCSS
Outgoing call routed to h323: for Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.447 6:11.674 CallSetup:0xb3231b90 Call OnSetUp
Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<pc>[sf6d465192]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.448 6:11.675 CallSetup:0xb3231b90 OpalCon
Applying string options:
2009/06/28 14:05:53.448 6:11.675 OpalMan
SetUpCall succeeded, call=Call[y1b92e0d81]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.451 6:11.678 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H225 Started
call thread
2009/06/28 14:05:53.451 6:11.678 CallSetup:0xb3231b90 OpalCon
OnSetUpConnectionCall[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.451 6:11.678 CallSetup:0xb3231b90 OpalEP
OnSetUpConnection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.451 6:11.678 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalCon
SetPhase from UninitialisedPhase to SetUpPhase for
Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.454 6:11.681 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalCon
SetPhase from SetUpPhase to SetUpPhase for
Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.454 6:11.681 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalTCP
Connecting to 130.87.34.42:1720 (local port=30000)
2009/06/28 14:05:53.492 6:11.719 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalTCP Started
connection to 130.87.34.42:1720 (if=140.112.102.80:30000)
2009/06/28 14:05:53.492 6:11.719 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H225 Sending
Setup PDU
2009/06/28 14:05:53.492 6:11.719 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalCon
Applying string options:
2009/06/28 14:05:53.497 6:11.724 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 MediaFormat
Removing codecs
PCM-16-48kHz,PCM-16-32kHz,PCM-16-16kHz,PCM-16,G.726-16k,G.726-24k,G.726-32k,G.726-40k,GSM-06.10,GSM-AMR,LPC-10,MS-GSM,MS-IMA-ADPCM,SpeexIETFNarrow-11k,SpeexIETFNarrow-15k,SpeexIETFNarrow-18.2k,SpeexIETFNarrow-24.6k,SpeexIETFNarrow-5.95k,SpeexIETFNarrow-8k,SpeexNB,SpeexWNarrow-8k,YUV420P,RFC4175_YCbCr-4:2:0,RGB32,RGB24,RFC4175_RGB,SIP-IM,T.140,H.224/H323AnnexQ,H.224/HDLCTunneling,Linear-16-Stereo-48kHz
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 Call
GetMediaFormats for Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
theora
H.261
H.261-CIF
H.261-QCIF
SpeexIETFWide-20.6k
SpeexWB
SpeexWide-20.6k
G.711-uLaw-64k
G.711-ALaw-64k
G.722-64k
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "SpeexIETFWide-20.6k"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: SpeexIETFWide-20.6k <1>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "SpeexWB"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "SpeexWide-20.6k"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: SpeexWide-20.6k <2>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "G.711-uLaw-64k"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: G.711-uLaw-64k <3>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "G.711-ALaw-64k"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.499 6:11.726 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: G.711-ALaw-64k <4>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "G.722-64k"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: G.722-64k <5>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "theora"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "H.261"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: H.261 <6>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "H.261-CIF"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: H.261-CIF <7>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Could
not find capability: "H.261-QCIF"
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: H.261-QCIF <8>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.500 6:11.727 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: UserInput/hookflash <9>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: UserInput/basicString <10>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: UserInput/dtmf <11>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Added
capability: UserInput/RFC2833 <12>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323 Found
capability: UserInput/RFC2833 <12>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 Call
GetOtherPartyConnection Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175]
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323
SetLocalCapabilities:
Table:
SpeexIETFWide-20.6k <1>
SpeexWide-20.6k <2>
G.711-uLaw-64k <3>
G.711-ALaw-64k <4>
G.722-64k <5>
H.261 <6>
H.261-CIF <7>
H.261-QCIF <8>
UserInput/hookflash <9>
UserInput/basicString <10>
UserInput/dtmf <11>
UserInput/RFC2833 <12>
Set:
0:
0:
SpeexIETFWide-20.6k <1>
SpeexWide-20.6k <2>
G.711-uLaw-64k <3>
G.711-ALaw-64k <4>
G.722-64k <5>
1:
H.261 <6>
H.261-CIF <7>
H.261-QCIF <8>
2:
UserInput/hookflash <9>
3:
UserInput/basicString <10>
UserInput/dtmf <11>
UserInput/RFC2833 <12>
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H225 Check
for Fast start by local endpoint
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H245 Default
OnSelectLogicalChannels, FastStartInitiate
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 Call
IsMediaBypassPossible Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175] session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalMan
IsMediaBypassPossible: session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalCon
IsMediaBypassPossible: default returns false
2009/06/28 14:05:53.501 6:11.728 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 RTP Cannot
find RTP session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.502 6:11.729 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 RTP_UDP Session
1, created with NAT flag set to 0
2009/06/28 14:05:53.502 6:11.729 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 RTP_UDP Session
1 created: 140.112.102.80:5062-5063 ssrc=3255873038
2009/06/28 14:05:53.707 6:11.934 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 RTP
Creating new session RTP_UDP
2009/06/28 14:05:53.707 6:11.934 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 Call
IsMediaBypassPossible Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175] session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.707 6:11.934 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalMan
IsMediaBypassPossible: session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.707 6:11.934 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 OpalCon
IsMediaBypassPossible: default returns false
2009/06/28 14:05:53.707 6:11.934 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 RTP Found
existing media session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.708 6:11.935 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 H323RTP
Receiver created using session 1
2009/06/28 14:05:53.708 6:11.935 H225 Caller:0xb31f0b90 Call
IsMediaBypassPossible Call[y1b92e0d81]-EP<h323>[localhost/8175] session 1
_______________________________________________
ekiga-list mailing list
[email protected]
http://mail.gnome.org/mailman/listinfo/ekiga-list
