Hallo,

 So would passing the strong version of IIA (and by strong version, I
 assume we are speaking about the one Dr. Arrow used) imply passing
 ICC?

As I said: Random Candidate, David Catchpole's Random Candidate, and Random Pairs satisfy IIA and violate ICC.

I am not talking about the IIA variant that you prefer, but Dr. Arrow's variant (which does not involve probabilities - unless I am mistaken), so my question to you stands.







---- Election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

Reply via email to