At 01:37 PM 8/30/2005, Warren Smith wrote:
PS. Although approval voting does not involve favorite betrayal, there is some reason to suspect it will lead to 2-party domination. See http://math.temple.edu/~wds/crv/NurseryEffect.html and note that range voting seems a lot less likely than AV to lead to 2-party domination. This is quite a subtle effect, and I certainly was not smart enough to predict it with mathematics alone - it required an experiment to make me see the light.
The conclusion does not seem, to me, at all warranted from the data. I'd invite Warren to, here, detail for us *precisely* how the data leads to that conclusion.
I've discussed this with him on the Range list, and it seems he thinks I'm being obtuse, so let me be obtuse in public, where more than one other can show me the error of my ways.
I'm also trying to be efficient, since I *am* trying to help with the Center for Range Voting, and there are plenty of other things than do than wrangle about details.... this is important, though, because Warren is citing his study (as he does above) as an attempt to prove Range superior to Approval, and specifically as a reason why the leaders of third parties would be practically suicidal to not embrace Range over Approval (not to mention IRV). If the study is flawed, if the conclusions are flawed, and the study is used in efforts to promote range, it will harm the cause.
---- Election-methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
