Hi Forest,
--- En date de : Dim 4.4.10, [email protected] <[email protected]> a écrit :
I waould like to advertise Delegable Yes No (DYN) voting again. It overcomes
the main difficulty with Approval, which is that the common voter will will not
feel sure about approving or disapproving some of the candidates.
Under DYN you check Y next to all of the candidates that you are sure that you
want to approve (like your favorite), you check N next to all of the candidates
that you are sure that you disapprove (like the candidate you most detest), you
leave blank the choices for the candidates you are not sure about, and you
circle the name of the approved candidate that you want to delegate the
remaining Y/N decisions to.
After the sure Y/N votes are counted, the candidates make their proxy votes for
their supporters on the delegated choices. The partial talleys already
available to them help to counteract disinformation from the media.
This is one way to solve the problem
49 C
26 A>B
25 B>A
Where the 25 threaten to bullet B.
--end quote
I'm not sure that scenario is one that would be repaired. To me that
isn't about poor information, it's a game of chicken inherent to a
lot of methods. You're just changing who gets to play.
I guess an example would be more like this:
51 A>B
5 B
44 C
If the 51 voters don't approve B then A can decline to add approval to
B at no risk at all.
I had a method some years ago called "withdrawable approval" I think,
which simulates something like this...
Kevin Venzke
----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info
