I think that the clone properties to look for in proportional representation 
methods are:

Increasing the clones in a clone set should not decrease the number of winners 
from the clone set and should not make a looser that is outside the clone set 
into a winner.
and
Decreasing the clones in a clone set should not increase the number of winners 
from the clone set and should not make a winner that is outside the clone set 
into a looser.

I don't know if the STV method I proposed or other STV methods that derive from 
clone-proof single winner methods satisfies these or not.

 


----
Election-Methods mailing list - see http://electorama.com/em for list info

Reply via email to