Bastien <[email protected]> writes:

> Hi Morgan,
>
> Morgan Smith <[email protected]> writes:
>
>> Kind of like how every time I report something to Emacs proper in
>> debbugs they mark it as "wishlist" and then stop responding :P
>
> You can obtain this by replying to a bug report like this:
>
> ,----
> | Subject: [FR] Support X in the exporter
> |   
> | Canceled.
> |   
> | This is a feature request rather than a bug: ...
> `----
>
> Your reply will appear in the same thread, but you changed the subject
> to [FR] ... and this is enough for BONE to detect a bug report.  When
> doing so, it does *not* close the parent bug, you need to explicitely
> close it with "Canceled." but the FR will be known as "related to" the
> bug request internally, and navigating through the "related" reports
> in BONE will show that.
>
> I believe this cover this use-case quite good enough... let me know!

I don't know if I can convince myself to open a feature request that
contains the "Canceled" keyword.  To me that is quite strange and blurs
the line between where the bug report stops and the feature request
starts.

I do really appreciate your software.  I will also respect your
decisions on this software.

However, I'm not a fan of "context".  I much prefer things that are
globally applicable.

For example, it's a little strange that using the "Confirmed" keyword in
the initial bug report doesn't mark it as confirmed.  So I have to keep
in mind that that keyword only works in certain contexts.

For this specific issue, I have to keep in mind that feature requests
and bugs operate with their own contexts that make certain operations
work and others not.

Reply via email to