Brad,
I just deleted a long response I had written about technology instead I am
going to keep it short.
Look at the times from the 1972 Olympics and then look at the times from the
1976 Olympics the records dropped about 2 seconds per 100 in almost every
event even more in the longer ones 10 seconds in the 400 free, 50 seconds in
the 1500 and the main new technology change was training and better
athletes, but swim suits had also changed to Lycra suits and we put on a
"Pan" like teflon spray called "Time Off". Now look at the times from 2004
with this years and again we see a lot of new world records but by fractions
of seconds per 100 not the 2 plus seconds of 1976. And look at the swimmers
this year, just look at pictures of Michael Philips then and now what do we
see, 2004 a tall skinny kid and now- a tall buffed man, the same can be said
for the women just look at someone like Dara Torres, would we have seen
someone built like her 4, 8 or in her case 24 years ago? NO! So what has
really changed again just like in 1976 is TRAINING and BETTER ATHLETES.
Reguardless of how much Speedo spins it (yes the compression and all the
rest may give me the psychologcal feeling that I can swim faster, I know
that after I spend $600 on a suit it better make me faster and if I believe
it and I also know I have TRAINED right I will swim faster) if I haven't
trained right even with the LZR I am not going to swim any faster.
----- Original Message -----
From: "Brad" <[email protected]>
To: "Swimming for Nova" <[email protected]>
Sent: Thursday, December 11, 2008 12:40 PM
Subject: Re: MORE ABOUT... Swimming Faster - Suits!
If the stance is going to be that technology is good for the sport,
then why place any limits at all? Why not allow full-blown neoprene
suits? Why not electronic pacing devices? Why not fins? I mean, we’re
already up to swimsuits that significantly alter the physical
characteristics of a large portion of a swimmer’s body, and its
behavior in the fluid medium. If the only goal is to enable swimmers
to swim the absolute fastest possible times, why stop there? And
Ahelee, are you equally as sanguine about allowing technology such as
full-body neoprene wetsuits for channel crossing swims, or does this
come down to whose ox is being gored?
I take nothing from the athletes, whose commitment would be no less,
who would train as rigorously and compete equally as hard with or
without the specialty suits. I view new records differently though,
increasingly representative of the influence of technology on the
sport, and less about the triumph of human endeavor. When a big part
of the media fuss in an oncoming Olympics is about the LZR suit rather
than about the athletes, at the only time that 99.9% of people pay any
attention at all to the sport of swimming, what kind of message is
being conveyed? How long before a jaded public sees our sport at the
elite level and the records there as having all the authenticity of a
WWE wrestling event?
Honestly, I don’t care. As I said, I respect the choices that people
make, and there’s room in the sport for all. Far be it from me to tell
other people how to run their lives - may a thousand theories prevail.
And it’s not that I’m not given to my own delusions – I was once
married, after all. I just choose, on a personal level, to keep mine
away from the pool. You’ll never catch me in one of those suits.
Peace out.