----------empyre- soft-skinned space---------------------- I want to ask some questions about the lists that were posted this week. To recap:
>From David's post - +-----------------+------------------+ | DIGITAL | POST-DIGITAL | +------------------------------------> | Non-zero sum | Zero-sum | | Objects | Streams | | Files | Clouds | | Programs | Apps | | SQL databases | NoSQL storage | | HTML | node.js/APIs | | Disciplinary | Control | | Administration | Logistics | | Connect | Always-on | | Copy/Paste | Intermediate | | Digital | Computal | | Hybrid | Unified | | Interface | Surface | | BitTorrent | Scraping | | Participation | Sharing/Making | | Metadata | Metacontent | | Web 2.0 | Stacks | | Medium | Platform | | Games | World | | Software agents | Compactants | | Experience | Engagement | | Syndication | Push notification| | GPS | Beacons (IoTs) | | Art | Aesthetics | | Privacy | Personal Cloud | | Plaintext | Cryptography | | Big data | Real-time | | Responsive | Anticipatory | | Tracing | Tracking | +------------------------------------> >From Rita's Post - Physical media Streaming media Local servers Clouds GUI and WIMP Other multimodal interfaces (affective, conversational, haptic, immersive, direct manipulation, perceptual) Storyspace iOS Floppy disks Apps with bonus features Amateurism Venture capital Listservs CommentPress, SocialBook Monograph Excerpts, chapters, paragraphs Library Repository Xerox copies Open Access as idea; paywall as practice Transcription Digitization Adaptations, versioning (sequential) Transmedial storytelling (simultaneous) File structures Slider bar Collage aesthetic (static) Networked books, liquid books (dynamic) Artists books The neo-analog Book as artifact The expanded book (not-codex, not-digital, not-game, not-conversation, not-collaborative content creation but situated in the interstitial field) Pay to read Pay to publish Editions Browser and system compatibility Bookseller Amazon Project Gutenberg Google books Borrower records, purchasing history Granular data collection File sharing File sharing Market monopolies Market monopolies ------------------------- Thanks David and Rita for these, I guess diagrammatics or concept maps are always something of a last resort during any period of disorientation, so thanks for putting together this thought-provoking set of distinctions to provide some coordinates. For whatever it's worth, I find Rita's map a bit more recognizable, if only because I'm ultimately not sure how some of these binaries are supposed to operate in David's model. I can't tell if something like "games | world", for instance, should be considered more along the lines of, say, Kostas Axelos or Jane McGonigal (maybe both?). Similarly, "art | aesthetics" also seems problematic: art discourses have always been deeply intertwined with aesthetic frameworks since Kant's engagements with Baumgarten; and the concept of media, moreover, itself arises alongside these genealogies of aesthetic thought. I wonder what kind of distinction is being made here, unless this is just a veiled reference to Bridle's New Aesthetic project? On the more technical side of things, why place a distinction between "Web 2.0 | The Stack"? Besides the fact that your list already recalls Tim O'Reilly's own set of marketing distinctions, surely this is actually a more or less consistent trajectory of intensification towards the consolidation and enclosure of internet infrastructures through corporate services. A key moment here would be the introduction of Amazon Web Services geared toward selling server-space to corporate clients in 2006, more or less contemporaneous with the user-generated content hype. On the other hand, maybe I'm just being a bit nit-picky. Perhaps it's best to just take the list as a provocation or speculative map for discussion. In this case, one thing I want to ask about is what kind of references are you drawing from to sketch out the post-digital. As opposed to the art-orientated definition from Alessandro and Florian - which they tend to trace back to Kim Cascone's 'Aesthetic of Failure' essay - there is a competing corporate literature that you're alluding to here. Can unpack that discourse in a bit more detail, especially when it comes to these points about it being a zero-sum game? For Rita's set of terms, meanwhile, I also wondered how I should read these - should I take it as a straight transition from left to right? Or something more like a dialectical situation, or Greimasian binary oppositions? The latter approaches actually might not be too far-fetched with some of these terms, since artist books and booksellers, for instance, are being recontextualized and revived in specific ways as a result of whatever's going on to the right. Just think about the fetishization of the print book as technical object by Visual Editions, or the maker-like slow theory artisanal processes of Univocal Publishing, or the revival of post-digital Xeroxed zines with Motto. I wonder if I could ask Rita whether it might be useful to also provide some explicit case studies, artworks, books or projects that might populate or transform the set up you've provided? There's material I know you've taught and written criticism on, but it might be useful to explicitly propose some cases to help us to grasp the stakes of the formation you're proposing. Cheers, -- Michael Dieter Lecturer Media Studies The University of Amsterdam Turfdraagsterpad 9 1012 XT Amsterdam http://home.medewerker.uva.nl/m.j.dieter/ _______________________________________________ empyre forum [email protected] http://www.subtle.net/empyre
