POLITICS: The Case of Varun Gandhi and the Fake Degrees At just 29 years old, Varun Gandhi is widely regarded as a rising star in his political party, the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). The BJP, which could sweep to power in India’s upcoming national elections when the results are announced on May 16th, is a Hindu nationalist party with a history of anti-Muslim rhetoric.
Recently Gandhi caused uproar when he was caught on tape using such rhetoric. In the aftermath it was discovered that he had lied about academic credentials from the *London School of Economics (LSE)* and the *School of African and Oriental Studies (SOAS)*, both constituent colleges of the University of London. The young Gandhi is an asset to the BJP because he is a high-level defector. His family is a political dynasty in the Congress Party, the secularist party currently holding on to power with a thin majority in the Lok Sabha (lower house of parliament). His aunt Sonia Gandhi is currently leader of the Congress. Additionally, his grandmother is the late former Prime Minister Indira Gandhi (Congress) and his great grandfather, Jawaharlal Nehru, was the first Prime Minister of India (Congress). After a family feud, Gandhi and his mother joined the BJP in 2004. (He explains his conversion to the BJP in a 2005 interview with the BBC.) In contrast to his usually soft demeanor when speaking to the media in English, Gandhi recently made a series of fiery Hindi speeches in Pilibhit, Uttar Pradesh, where he is the BJP’s candidate for the Lok Sabha. In them he threatens violence against Muslims, saying for example that after the election the “Lotus Hand” (the BJP’s emblem) would cut the throats of the “circumcised.” That is of course a derogatory reference to Muslims that has more or less the same effect as the ‘N’-word in American politics. Gandhi has been censured by the national Electoral Commission and was arrested on March 28th on charges of inciting communal violence.The BJP issued a statement “dissociating” itself from Gandhi’s comments but affirming that he remains its candidate for Pilibhit. The lack of any apology on Gandhi’s part angered a number of people, who gathered signatures for a petition allowing alumni of the *LSE* and *SOAS*to condemn the remarks of their fellow-alumnus Varun Gandhi. The only problem is, as Raghu Karnad discovered, that Gandhi is not really an alumnus of either institution. He was never officially part of the student body at the LSE (rather he participated in a distance learning program after having been denied admission to the normal course) and he dropped out of SOAS before receiving the M.Sc. he claimed he had earned. This has now been confirmed by officials at both colleges. Karnad wrote a piece in *Outlook India* arguing that Varun Gandhi is the antithesis of the liberal values of LSE and SOAS. Unfortunately for Gandhi, he made these claims in a court petition, which means that he could be charged with perjury. Still, his exaggerations are not as bad as other recent blow ups around the world: - Ali Kordan, a long-serving Interior Minister of Iran, was forced out of the government after his Oxford doctorate was exposed as an absurdly crude fake (having been issued by the non-existent “London Oxford University”) and he attempted to bribe MPs not to impeach him. - A few years ago, Mamata Banerjee, veteran politician, who was a cabinet minister in Indian Government for many years, claimed to have a doctorate from “East Georgia University,” which is no more real than London Oxford University. - H. James Wasser, the Superintendent of Public Schools in Freehold, NJ was recently discovered to have bought a fake PhD. But why did they do it, asks the *Times of India*. In Gandhi’s case, the mention of the degrees was ironically in a court filing which presented his (false) academic qualifications as evidence that he was an upstanding citizen. Perhaps others do it for reasons of pride. People are able to perpetrate such frauds because the entire system of academic qualifications runs mostly on trust and much less on government inspection. That trust is often broken: India’s University Grants Commission has published a list of 22 fake universities in India that issue degrees without accreditation. In the United States, such organizations are known as “diploma mills” (click the link for the *NYT*’s account of one egregious example) and are able to flourish because the national Department of Education does not accredit universities. Thus, in states where there are not stringent laws regulating how academic qualifications are granted, almost anyone can start printing degrees. And then of course there is the problem of honorary degrees, which is big business since universities often reward donors by giving them an honorary PhD. Of course, one is supposed to always mention that the degree is honorary but being called “Dr So-and-So” has an allure. The issue of Varun Gandhi’s academic qualifications and his anti-Muslim attitudes are two different matters, but both involve a similar deception. In the 2005 BBC interview mentioned above, Gandhi claims to have seen no “minority-bashing” in the BJP, and yet here he is five years later, unmistakably doing just that. So, are Indians simply so hung up about a 'phoren' degree they want one even though they have no claim to it? Is this proof we love all things 'phoren'? Or do we have a talent and aptitude for deception and fakery? "Foreign things have a status value which the swadeshi doesn't," says social scientist Shiv Vishwanathan. In other words, another instance of our love of the foreign tag, a colonial hangover. More important, when people tom-tom degrees from non-existent universities, it should be seen as an "appeal to an intellect they don't possess", adds Vishwanathan. Dipankar Gupta, professor of *sociology* at Delhi's Jawaharlal Nehru University says that "a degree from either the UK or the US matters a lot (to) people in the developing world". But he adds that any dispassionate analysis shows "that some international universities are superior to ours and it helps to study there. But for many, it's not about acquiring knowledge, it's about showing off." It is a platitude that India still prizes education above most other attributes. A highly qualified person commands more respect than one without. This increases manifold if the degree is from, say Oxford or Cambridge. Sometimes, discovery of a *fake degree* can save lives. A few years ago, police caught 'Dr' Vikramjeet Singh, who claimed a degree from the Karanganda Medical Institute in Kazakhastan. He was employed by a Delhi hospital. * * * --~--~---------~--~----~------------~-------~--~----~ You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups "English Learner's Cafe" group. To post to this group, send email to [email protected] To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [email protected] For more options, visit this group at http://groups.google.com/group/english_learners?hl=en -~----------~----~----~----~------~----~------~--~---
