Hi Natalia,

The point of embedding "Develop solution increment" in "Develop the 
architecture" is to emphasize the the architecture should be implemented.
However, there may be development work in support of other goals that 
might not be strictly architectural, for example, you may want to 
implement some key features early to to get user feedback.  So other 
development work may be going on in parallel.

Others have also found this distinction confusing, so in other delivery 
processes, such as the new practices-based RUP delivery processes, I have 
tended to put architecture and develop increment activities in parallel.

OpenUP is intended to be customized, so you should feel free to use either 
approach.

Bruce MacIsaac
Manager RMC Method Content
bmaci...@us.ibm.com
408-250-3037 (cell)



From:   Nalalia Lucero <nvluc...@gmail.com>
To:     epf-dev@eclipse.org
Cc:     Lean <leandro.u...@gmail.com>
Date:   02/06/2012 12:23 PM
Subject:        [epf-dev] OpenUP Question
Sent by:        epf-dev-boun...@eclipse.org



 
Dear,
We Natalia and Leandro from San Luis, Argentina. We are currently 
developing the thesis for the degree of Bachelor of Computer Science at 
the Universidad Nacional de San Luis. This thesis is based on OpenUP 
automation using workflow technology. We contacted Mr. Ricardo Balduino 
who graciously answered some questions and put us in touch with mail list.
 
We have a doubt in the Elaboration phase, with the activities "Develop the 
Architecture" and "Develop Solution Increment".  Within this link 
http://epf.eclipse.org/wikis/openup/process.openup.base/deliveryprocesses/Elaboration%20Phase_F6EBBC8B.html?proc=_SuWj4dOPEdyqlogshP8l4g&path=_SuWj4dOPEdyqlogshP8l4g,_ieYHIVQwEd2i9JHp7xurvw&nodeId=34e65f53
   we can see that the activity "Develop the Architecture" contains the 
activity "Develop Solution Increment" and the task "Refine the 
Architecture". 
The questions are:
 
1) Which of these two tasks is done first? ("Develop Solution Increment or 
Refine the Architecture)
Our doubt arises because research found this site  
http://process.osellus.com/sites/wiki/openup/Wiki%20Pages/WorkDefinition%20-%20Develop%20the%20Architecture.aspx
, where first perform the task "Refine the Architecture" and then the 
activity "Develop Solution Increment", contradicting the established order 
in the process.
 
 
2) What is the purpose in this phase have two activities " Develop 
Solution Increment" ?
 
 We await your response. Thank you very much.!!
Regards
Leandro y Natalia_______________________________________________
epf-dev mailing list
epf-dev@eclipse.org
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/epf-dev

_______________________________________________
epf-dev mailing list
epf-dev@eclipse.org
https://dev.eclipse.org/mailman/listinfo/epf-dev

Reply via email to