Eds discussion of the different models is correct a C that has been 
upmodeled to a D can never revert back. I don't think its important
if FAA records list an update or not. My lawyer friends tell me 
aircraft logbooks are legal documents and an entry into a logbook 
making a C a D makes it a D irrespective of whats on file in Ok city.   
What he did not address is that between 1946 -when the C,s were 
manufactured-  and 1947 when the  D models came out the Feds changed 
the regulations applying to the certification of light aircraft. In 
part the new regulations had some language applicable to fire standards 
ie the stainless sheet metal above the  header tank. Frankly I am 
surprised that the feds permitted header tanks at all and it would be 
interesting to know what lobbying pressure from the airframe 
manufactures occured to permit the continuation of the practice in 
existing types. Frankly I can't think of any new post war type 
certificates issued  with header tanks.

I talked to several graybeards who were active in aviation in the early 
postwar years and several reflected that they thought that the fed 
action- new licensing standards- to a large degree was based on 
experience in aircraft technology acquired during WWII. The feds wanted 
such technology applied to new models such as the Bonanzaa and Navion 
hence the Ercoupe D- and later models-  was licensed under the new 
regulatory language. Coupes just got dragged along piecemeal.

The FAAs mindset seems to be is a D would be a safer aircraft and to 
retrogress to a C would be reverting to a less safe aircraft.  In 
reality a C and D are essentially the same airframe the elevator 
travel  issue being nothing more than changing the position of the 
stops. The D I believe also had a larger trim tab which is addressed in 
the 1320 lb STC.  In the real world of aerodynamics it does not make 
much sense  but the rules are the the rules. I am sure that a lot of 
guys are more tuned into the history than I but this reflects the 
essentials.

Len    


Reply via email to