On Jan 18, 2009, at 10:23 PM, Mark Miller wrote:

2009/1/18 Brendan Eich <[email protected]>:
The other unreserved context in JS1.7 and later is after the 'function' keyword. Unambiguous, complementary, useful for some cases. It's easy to tweak ES3.1's grammar to allow keywords in this context too. Thoughts?

It would be surprising to be able to say "function if(x) {return x;}"
but not "if(33);".

Surprising to a PL/1 fanboy :-P.

Seriously, if that is surprising, then is it surprising that

var obj = {if: 42};
with (obj)
    print(if);

doesn't work? Don't bust on 'with', the same issue arises in global code with 'this' or equivalent ('global', 'window').


On property names, we symmetrically unreserve both
the definition (by object literal) and the use (by ".").

Definition is just sugared assignment, in ES3 at any rate. You can't assign

if = 4;

even though you can (in ES3.1 or JS1.7) say

this.if = 4;

at top level.

The best real-world example is when implemening something in JS that has to match an interface across a language bridge with a reasonable method name such as 'delete'. In such a case you could certainly use an object initialiser or assignment (doesn't matter which), but you couldn't give the function the intrinsic name 'delete'. Named functions have their uses, not so much for recursive calls as for better diagnostics and less inscrutable pretty-printing results.

Symmetry has less to do with any of this than utility. There are several symmetries or relations here ("definition", assignment, reference). Special-pleading for one kind of symmetry doesn't resolve the argument from utility.

No one outside of the PL/1 community wants 'var var = var;' or other such keywords in the unqualified reference sense to be possible. But we've agreed (based on precedent) to two out of the three contexts in which JS1.7 allows keywords to be used as identifiers. The use-case for the third, function names, is strong enough that we implemented it. I think it ought to be in 3.1, so I guess I'll put this on the f2f agenda.

/be
_______________________________________________
Es-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/es-discuss

Reply via email to