Comments to 1st Edition / Draft 3 May 2012

These are very similar to previous comments.

** >> p1, 3: Need update to later version of specs: Unicode, CLDR. Especially with requested updates to CLDR.

** >> p2, 4.3: Does not state what the cultural requirements are. Only knowing the 'people involved' give me any expectation of the output.

** >> Much specification of how the API machinery operates, but not about the expected output.

** >> p16 11.3.2, The tailoring docs are moving to UTR#35 from UTS#10 as of last UTC. May be better to refer to UTR#35 for tailoring.

** >> p21-22, p25, p26: again, need more examples to evaluate this.

** >> p30, 14: Should harmonize the base localeCompare, toLocaleString, etc with default locale behavior. If a locale isn't specified, shouldn't the behavior be similar to using the Collator, Formatter, etc with the default locale?



_______________________________________________
es-discuss mailing list
[email protected]
https://mail.mozilla.org/listinfo/es-discuss

Reply via email to