>I was under the impression that the audio and data disks work in computer
>burners, HOWEVER ONLY AUDIO disks work in stand-alone burners. Can anyone
>confirm this?

That is generally true.  Those classified as "consumer" decks require the 
expensive, royalty-inclusive 'audio' or 'music' discs, which are of 
essentially identical manufacture *except* they have an embedded signal bit 
in them that tells the "consumer" deck this is a royalty-paid disc.  What's 
worse is that these decks have the same SCMS (Serial Copy Management 
System) circuitry in them that plagued 'consumer' DAT decks, which embeds a 
signal in the copy made that tells other 'consumer' decks that 'this is a 
copy, he's had his one allowed copy, this copy isn't copyable.'  (that's 
the significance of that 'digital copy permitted' flag you see in some 
burner software; PC burners ignore those flags but 'consumer' standalones 
do not).

As with DAT decks before them (this all started with the RIAA freaking over 
the advent of DAT in the 80s, certain THAT technology would be the one to 
decimate their sales), there is an exemption for standalones classified as 
"professional' decks, which is why Pro decks like the Tascams and HHBs 
happily eat regular Mitsui, TY etc, AND ignore the one-copy-only SCMS 
flag.  They do a vastly better job of extracting than the 'consumer' 
standalones, too  - in one informal test reported here or somewhere the HHB 
consistently produced the same file as EAC.  Don't be too leery of a pro 
standalone in your show's lineage, but avoid shows with 'consumer' decks 
like the Philips in their family tree.  ;-}

w
_______________________________________________
etree mailing list <[EMAIL PROTECTED]>
http://mail.etree.org/mailman/listinfo/etree

Reply via email to