Tesla Model 3 “Phantom Drain” compared to Model S and Model X
June 10, 2018 Simon Alvarez
Phantom Drain Info Graphic
Did Tesla Fix Phantom Drain on Model 3?
Tesla Model 3 currently leads the pack in terms of having the highest
parasitic battery drain, or better known as “Phantom Drain”, over Tesla’s
more mature Model S and Model X.
Phantom Drain represents the amount of charge an electric vehicle loses when
it is not being driven or operated by a person, similar to how smartphones
lose battery power while in standby mode. In the case of Tesla vehicles, the
battery discharges while the car is not being driven in order to provide
power to its onboard electronics and auxiliary functions, such as the
battery’s thermal management system. According to the Model 3 Owners Guide [
], the vehicle, on average, should discharge at a rate of around 1% per day,
similar to Tesla’s quotes for the Model S and Model X’s battery drain
However, looking at data collected through TezLab, a popular app among the
Tesla owners community that tracks vehicle power usage, efficiency, and
other statistics, Ben Sullins of the Teslanomics YouTube channel was able to
see a significantly larger discharge rate from the Model 3. Ben was also
able to compare the differences in vampire drain between the 3,855 Model S,
1,281 Model X, and 362 Model 3 being sampled.
Looking at the distribution of Phantom Drain between the Model S, Model 3
and Model X, it could be seen that around 60% of TezLab’s users experienced
drain levels similar to Tesla’s quoted levels, which are on the 1-2% range
per day. However, the differences between battery drain of the Model 3 and
the Model S and X become more prominent over time. It’s worth noting that
any parasitic losses as a result of TezLab connecting to the vehicle on a
recurring basis may also be accounted for in the results being reported.
As noted by Ben, the Model 3’s Phantom Drain levels exhibited volatility
sometime during the November 2017 to January 2018 period. Ben’s recent
real-world range test using his RWD Long Range Model 3 on an LA to Las Vegas
route showed an even more drastic level of Phantom Drain [
], with his car losing almost 20 miles of range while he and his companion
ate lunch. That’s a loss of more than 6% from the Model 3’s rated 310-mile
range in the span of an hour.
The drain levels of Model 3 owners using the TezLab app [
] has started becoming more normalized, suggesting that the longer the
vehicles are on the road, and as Tesla pushed firmware updates to its Model
3 fleet, the more consistent the cars’ drain levels became. Back in 2015, we
covered a Model S that lost an average of 2.3% rated range per day [
] while the vehicle was left in 16-degree Fahrenheit (-9 C) weather.
Overall, Tezlab’s data shows that the Model 3 is becoming more consistent as
the maturity of the vehicle’s software is improving. Other features like its
battery thermal management systems and its auxiliary functions are improving
over time as well. These improvements are a trademark of Tesla, which is
known as one of the only carmakers whose vehicles get better after they roll
off the showrooms.
Watch Ben’s video on the Phantom Drain of the Model 3 compared to the Model
S and Model X.
New Tesla Roadster will come with SpaceX rocket thrusters …
June 11, 2018
'Difficult but necessary' Elon Musk defends job cuts as Tesla searches for
June 11, 2018
For EVLN EV-newswire posts use:
Sent from: http://electric-vehicle-discussion-list.413529.n4.nabble.com/
Please discuss EV drag racing at NEDRA (http://groups.yahoo.com/group/NEDRA)