[I am starting a new thread on this question because I feel I may have confused matters with increasingly elaborate thought experiments in my posts to Eric Cavalcanti's thread on observation selection effects.]
The occurence of events which at first glance seem to be very unlikely should not necessarily surprise us. For example, the probability that a particular person wins first prize in a lottery may be one in a million, but the probability that SOMEONE wins first prize is usually greater than 50% for most lotteries. We can avoid confusion by being clear on what the desired outcome is before the event takes place: Pr(someone wins)=1/2, Pr(John Smith wins)=1/1,000,000.
Consider the situation in a generic ensemble theory in which every possible outcome occurs. Clearly, Pr(some version of John Smith wins)=1. The outcome (some version of John Smith wins) is analogous to the outcome (someone wins) in the above example.
Now, if some version of John Smith wins, it may be argued that this is surprising, because there is only a 1/1,000,000 probability that that PARTICULAR version wins. But for this to be surprising, we would have to specify the desired outcome before the event takes place: just as in the single world example above we have to specify that a particular individual will be the winner, in the ensemble theory we would have to further specify that a particular version of that individual will be the winner.
The difficulty is that it is impossible to specify a particular version of a particular individual in an ensemble theory. The different worlds do not come labelled in any way, and it is not possible in general to pick out any attribute which will single out a particular world or individual, because the only necessary difference is the outcome of interest. In other words, the only way to specify which version of John Smith will win is to specify the outcome (that version of John Smith who will win, will win), which is obviously not going to lead to any surprises.
Smart Saving with ING Direct – earn 5.25% p.a. variable rate: http://ad.au.doubleclick.net/clk;7249209;8842331;n?http://www.ingdirect.com.au/burst6offer.asp?id=8