Thank you
John M

On 1/14/07, Brent Meeker <[EMAIL PROTECTED]> wrote:

John Mikes wrote:
> Stathis P wrote:1-14-07:
> John,
> So if a child comes to you and asks what shape the Earth is, will you
> reply that some think it's flat, and some think it's spherical, and for
> sake of not being thought ignorant by the majority maybe he should
> say it's spherical, but in fact there is no reason to prefer one theory
> in this regard over another?
> Stathis
> Cute, I certainly would consider the mental level of the "child" and
> give an appropriately formulated  information not contradictory to my
> (your) present 2007AD cognitive (science?) inventory.
> I think your question arose from the controversy upon my (poorly
> expressed) liberal stance about   considering everybody's belief system
> as his own/entire mental world, maybe different from mine (or yours) and
> in most cases impenetrable from another belief system because the values
> and even the concepts (e.g. evidence?) are differently formulated,
> accepted and understood. Our today's scientific mindset IS a belief
> system - more than just one, this list is a good example for that.
> I did not reflect to questions like "which one is good, better, worse,
> because value systems are identified within the belief system and I
> would not 'judge' the values of another system based upon the values in
> my system. A missionary may do so, or a fascist dictator..

But you make a value decision not to reflect on the question and
consequently you cannot judge the actions of the missionary or the fascist
dictator.  Albert Schweitzer or Idi Amin, they just have different belief
systems and can't be you.

But to have a value system that cannot be used to judge others is the same
as having no ethics at all.  To refuse of criticize or sanction others in
society is the position referred to as a 'free-rider' (c.f. Matt Ridley
"The Origins of Virtue").

Brent Meeker


You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to [EMAIL PROTECTED]
For more options, visit this group at

Reply via email to