The Day The Earth Stood Still - remake version in cinemas now

Just saw it - at the very first session at 9.30 AM.

This film is a whole lot better than the reviews make out and a whole  
lot better than I expected.

Keanu Reeves is Keanu as usual and only acts with his left eyebrow,  
but this works for once, given the part  (I had suspected this would  
be the case)

Gort (the fearsome robot) is great but I reckon they didn't make  
enough of him.

The ending is a bit trite and perfunctory but its a film that has such  
a powerful message that it needs to be plonked straight in the  
audience's lap quickly.

The music has no chance to add anything to the noisy soundtrack, so  
Bernard Hermann's reputation is safe. I cannot remember anything about  
the music and I listened hard

Some great script moments:

Keanu Klaatu: "Nothing ever dies. The universe wastes nothing. Things  
are only ever......transformed."

"I tried to reason with you. You treat the Earth the way you treat  
each other."

John Cleese to Klaatu (cameo role as a physicist): "Help us to change!  
We are at the precipice. At the precipice we can change."

Perhaps faced with the ironclad guarantee of our extinction as a  
species we COULD do it? But we have to be forced to confront it by an  
intelligence far greater than our own. That's the movie's message.  
It's a little unfortunate in my view that the process of our  
extinction - in typical Hollywood fashion - is halted before it has  
completely run its course, so we get let off the hook and the sun  
rises again tomorrow on the human race, so it remains a mere  
conjecture that we can change.

In the original, the Earth's energy economy is halted for 24 hours as  
a demonstration of superior force which convinces us we have no other  
option. Weak.

In this version, the extinction process is commenced (using matter- 
eating quantum nano-bugs that self-replicate at an impossibly fast  
rate, becoming a tornado that whips around the world) and this process  
looks set to wipe out humans and their structures in a couple of hours  
at most. Keanu Klaatu - for some unbelievably treacly, sentimental  
Hollywood non-reason becomes convinced at the last moment that humans  
may be capable of change after all and calls a halt to the process and  
goes home in his beaut glowing orb.

THEN all the power goes off. So we are left with a three-quarters- 
destroyed civilisation and no energy economy. We are hunter-gatherers  
once again. Even though it comes across as a bit unconvincing in the  
movie, the concept is stronger than in the original because rather  
than leave Gort behind to keep an eye on things after the lights come  
back on, the lights NEVER come back on, so we don't HAVE the option to  
misbehave any longer. Strong.

Take a break from your computer keyboards and get into the fresh air -  
of a dark cinema!



A thought once thought cannot be unthought  - Edward de Bono

It is impossible to delete information from this universe - Wei Dai



(612) 9389 4239  or  0431 723 001

You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at

Reply via email to