David Nyman wrote:
> On Sep 23, 3:20 am, Brent Meeker <meeke...@dslextreme.com> wrote:
>  >> What would make a theory of consciousness a
>>> physical theory would be a normal causal account of a succession of
>>> physical states, the experience that accompanies them, and the precise
>>> relation between them.  Such a theory would of course escape the
>>> vulnerability to accusations of lack of meaningful physical commitment
>>> inherent in MR.
>> Such a theory is available.  It is the evolutionary account of the
>> development of consciousness, c.f. Thomas Metzinger, Antonio Damasio,
>> Julian Jaynes, Daniel Dennett.
> Well, I've read Damasio, Jaynes and Dennett, all at some length, and
> whilst each offers fascinating insight from his own perspective, I
> don't think that any of them could be said to offer a physical causal
> theory of first-person experience in the sense we are discussing
> here.  Does Metzinger go any further?  I've got quite a lot on my
> reading list so I've been resisting the temptation to add him to it
> for the moment - should I succumb?
>> Knowing the physical function of a species sensors and the evolutionary 
>> history
>> of it's environment you could infer what it is conscious of.
> True, but this is to give a third-person behavioural account, not a
> first-person experiential one.  I'm right in assuming that you don't
> intend to offer a third-person account as an eliminativist dismissal
> of first-person experience - yes?  I didn't think that was your
> position, but you've made this kind of comment so frequently recently
> that I'm starting to wonder.

I don't have "a position" on such an unsettled question.  But I think what you 
are asking 
  is incoherent - a first-person account physical account of experience.  Can 
you give an 
example what such an account might look like?


You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups 
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to everything-list@googlegroups.com
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to 
For more options, visit this group at 

Reply via email to