On 9/22/2011 10:02 AM, Bruno Marchal wrote:
I think what Bruno calls the 323 principle is questionable.
Can I deduce from this that UDA1-7 is understood. This shows already that either the
universe is "little" or physics is (already) a branch of computer science (even if there
is a physical universe).
It doesn't comport with QM. Bruno gets around this by noting that computationally a
classical computer can emulate a quantum system. But I think that assumes an
*isolated* quantum system.
Because the quantum entanglement is in principle unbounded and so it would take an
infinite classical computer to emulate exactly. In practice we are always satisfied with
good approximations. The Hilbert space has N dimensions representing the configurations
we calculate. We don't include an N+1st dimension to include "something else happens";
but it is implicitly there.
All real quantum systems big enough to be quasi-classical systems are impossible to
But then you have to assume that your brain is some infinite quantum system (but then
comp is false).
Maybe not infinite but arbitrarily entangled with part of the universe which is finite but
So I'm afraid this pushes the substitution level all the way down.
Yes, I'm afraid that will be the case.
I tend to look at that as a reductio; but I'm not sure where the error is. I think it is
in not allowing that one need only *approximate* the function of the brain module the
doctor replaces. But the idea of digital approximation is fuzzy. The digital computation
itself has no fuzz.
If it's all the way down, then as Craig notes, there's really no difference between
emulation and duplication.
But then you are, like Craig, assuming that mechanism is false. This is my point, if we
want primitive matter, comp is false. (or comp implies no primitive matter, or the
falsity of physicalism).
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to email@example.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at