On 16.09.2012 19:03 Craig Weinberg said the following:
On Sunday, September 16, 2012 12:34:47 PM UTC-4, Evgenii Rudnyi
You may want to look at
Galen Strawson, Selves: An Essay in Revisionary Metaphysics
He proves that selves exist. Interestingly enough he does it based
on the materialist framework.
p. 11 �For the moment, though, the brief is to show that selves
exist, and that they�re things or objects or �substances� of
some sort, and hence, given materialism, physical objects. One
possibility is that there are in fact no better candidates for the
title of �physical object� than selves � even if there are
others that are as good.�
p. 11 �This last suggestion is likely to strike many as obviously
false, but this reaction may stem in part from a failure to think
through what it is for something to be physical, on a genuine or
realistic materialist view, and, equally, from a failure to think
through what it is for something to be a thing or object.�
Thanks Evgenii. I have been meaning to check out Strawson for a while
actually. I agree that the self is physically and concretely real,
but I don't think it is an object. The self is the subject. I see and
agree with what Strawson is saying about the necessity of expanding
our sense of what is physical, and I understand why he thinks it
makes sense to think of the self as more of a 'thing' than anything -
and I would agree, except that 'thing' is a term of objectification.
I can only see myself as a thing in theory. In fact, who I am has no
thingness at all from my own perspective. There is no object here,
nothing which can be defined in terms of size, weight, temperature,
etc. A subject is made of qualities that have only figurative
dimensions, not literal body qualities.
According to Strawson, what exists as a thing is
SUBJECT OF EXPERIENCE-AS-SINGLE-MENTAL-THING
for short SESMET.
Hence no contradiction.
You received this message because you are subscribed to the Google Groups
"Everything List" group.
To post to this group, send email to email@example.com.
To unsubscribe from this group, send email to
For more options, visit this group at