Hi Ben, I thought I would share my answer to your
messages with the Mandrake crowd and see what they
make of it.  Here it goes.
....
Bear in mind that Mozilla is not Netscape 5.0.  I am not
sure if they share much if any code at all.  I suspect
that Netscape 5.0 will have SOME of Mozilla's work on it.

The goals are totally different.

Mozilla's goal is to have a slim, fast, efficient, 
standards compliant browser/email/news/java platform
with a good set of API's for applications that want
to hook into their code.  This is the end result of
the Open-Source/GPL crew that is working on it.

Netscape/AOL's goal is a Browser that features
shopping sites, channel bars (for advertising and
shopping), and all sorts of bells, whistles and
plug ins.  For instance, things like Netscape Radio
with its advertising, the built in MP3 decoder with
sites that will SELL you the MP3 music, and all sorts
of active content for businesses to put stuff on
your screen, yours speakers and your brain.

The difference will be about 2 MB vs 23 MB size.

Make no mistake, Netscape 5.0 is NOT Mozilla. 

What begs the question is to what extent are the
two camps committed to each other.  I doubt that
Netscape/AOL has any interest in the Mozilla project
other than it can save them from paying to develop
future Netscape versions or functionality.  I think
that AOL's vision is to have the core functionality
of their future browsers be the Mozilla engine.

For us Linux users, I seriously doubt that we are
interested much in the additional 21 MB of code designed
to promote the interests of advertising and marketing
companies.  The squabbles between AOL and the Mozilla
project are rooted on this.  You will hear a lot of
protests that my words are off-base or not true, but
every one of those voices has vested interest in masking
the truth.

Opera, with its price tag of about $40 can afford to
develop a browser that is free of all the marketing
stuff, which is why so far it fits on a floppy.  While
its not open source, and fully commercial, it is a 
stand-alone product that does not depend on free
give away.

Both Netscape and Microsoft give their browsers away
for free.  When did this all start?  Answer:  When the
browsers became a gateway for advertising.  Like
"search buttons" that lead to advertising sites.  Or
lead to search engines that prioritize and order the
search results based on the amount of money they are
paid for.  Or bookmarks that are predefined for you
and is nothing but a listing of advertisers.  Or for
the Netcenter page showing on the email page when no
message is selected, etc. etc. ad-nauseam.

As both Mozilla, now at milestone 10, and Netscape 5.0
approach release date, you will see a lot of this come
to a head.  You will see either a bloated Mozilla, or
a Netscape 5.0 that takes over their coding and embelishes
it, or the two camps split and Mozilla becomes a force
of its own.  Then they lose the AOL money and who knows
what happens next.  My take on it is that ALL of us will
be losers on this whole fiasco.

Stay tuned, we will see this all work out by year's end
most likely.

-- 
Ramon Gandia ============= Sysadmin ============== Nook Net
http://www.nook.net                            [EMAIL PROTECTED]
285 West First Avenue                     tel. 907-443-7575
P.O. Box 970                              fax. 907-443-2487
Nome, Alaska 99762-0970 ==== Alaska Toll Free. 888-443-7525

Reply via email to