So sprach Ron Heron am Fri, Nov 17, 2000 at 06:38:35PM -0800:
> This is a matter of how you look at it.  If you have
> an ext2 partition, you can make that partition
> reserfs.  The issue is that you copy the contents of
> the partition to a temp location, run mkresierfs, and

Okay, if you have enough space available, then you are right.  But basically
you don't _convert_ the ext2 fs, you totally scrap the fs, and put a
reiserfs on the same partition.  But I suppose that's only nitpicking.

> is great, however for mass storage.  Ext2 takes 22
> minutes to do e2fsck on 2 15G drives, reiser takes 22
> seconds!

Plus reiserfs doesn't waste as much space on big systems as ext2 does, and
you can't run out of inodes - you can't because reiserfs dynamically creates
them.

> If you don't have a commercial system, and want that
> nervous, fuzzy feeling about using bleeding edge
> developments, go for it.  Otherwise, just stick to the
> old ext2 and be happy.

Hmm, I'd rather say it the other way around.  Granted, I haven't tested it
on a heavily loaded production system (because I don't have access to such a
system), but I would try it even there.  Simply the reason that it is a
journaling system would be a good enough reason for *ME*.  Plus there's a
speed advantage, and that I haven't had any problems with reiserfs in the
last, hmm? year?, or so that I use reiserfs exclusively (well, about at
least.  I still have a 100meg ext2 boot partition).

What exactly are the reasons that you would not trust reiserfs for a
production system?  Do you know of any scenarios where reiserfs always
fails?  I know that there are some issues with NFS on a reiserfs fs, and I
know that there are some troubles with kernel software raid.  Anything else?

Alexander Skwar
-- 
How to quote:   http://learn.to/quote (german) http://quote.6x.to (english)
Homepage:       http://www.digitalprojects.com   |   http://www.dp.ath.cx
GnuPG ID:       59F6A6F5  FP: DC8AFA56C492EE6058D5 BAA62EEE3AD559F6A6F5
ICQ:            7328191         Uptime: 3 days 7 hours 7 minutes

Keep in touch with http://mandrakeforum.com: 
Subscribe the "[EMAIL PROTECTED]" mailing list.

Reply via email to