> > It almost seems as if the three gunas are 
> > telling them to STFU.  :-)
> >
blusc0ut:
> Well, I think the gunas don't like to be
> exposed. They want to keep the show
> running. If you make a movie, you don't 
> remind the audience that it's just a
> movie, you want them to, eh, believe it's 
> real.
>
So, you're thinking that, just like in a 
"movie", the physical world we live in is
just like a picture show, not real, yet 
not unreal? And, that because we have "free
will" we can change the physical properties
of basic elements and enter into history 
and cause change to occur, at will?

The "three gunas" are the forces of nature,
the primary constiuents of prakriti. It is
totally separate from the Purusha. If the
prakriti is an illusion, are you saying that
we should believe that individual jivas have
"free will" to do as they please, and that
yogis can make their karma just disappear?

If so, there would be chaos instead of order
in the human universe, since without the laws
of nature or causation, events that happen 
could not be associated with actions. 

Then, Arjuna in the Battle of Kurukshetra, 
could have raped and murdered his entire 
family, without the slightest consequences. 

The question is, does Karma (and the three
gunas) have a *mental* component or not?

Reply via email to