Le 14 févr. 2016 à 00:42, Albert Graef <aggr...@gmail.com> a écrit :
> It seems that for some reason libHTTPFaust.so contains http_fetch() without 
> external linkage (note the lowercase t):
> 
>   $ nm /usr/local/lib/libHTTPDFaust.so|grep http_fetch
>   00000000000469b0 t _Z10http_fetchPKcPPc
> 
> In contrast, the static libHTTPFaust.a library *does* have http_fetch() as an 
> external symbol (note the uppercase T):
> 
>   $ nm /usr/local/lib/libHTTPDFaust.a|grep http_fetch
>   0000000000000756 T _Z10http_fetchPKcPPc
> 
> Funny. And in fact the static build (`make STATIC=1`) works ok, the binary 
> links and runs all right. I haven't looked into why this happens yet. Do 
> others (non-Arch users) see the same issue?

Hum, … I did not actually tested  the dynamic HTTPD library compilation, I'll 
test (and possibly export this http_fetch symbol as pure C maybe ?

> 
> Polyphony implementation:
> 
> Very nice, but not *quite* there yet IMHO. The Jack MIDI implementation is 
> looking good AFAICT right now, but I have the following pet peeves with the 
> voice allocation:
> 
> - No voice stealing. Try playing a fifth note with 4 voice polyphony when all 
> the voices are playing already. :) IMHO voice stealing should be the default 
> or at least selectable as an option.
> 
> - Voices seem to be shut down immediately when the corresponding note-off is 
> received. Consequently, note-offs produce audible clicks because the voice 
> doesn't have time to go through its release phase. To fix this, voices should 
> be managed in a round-robin (LIFO) fashion instead of FIFO (which seems to be 
> the case right now), and shouldn't be shut down before their signal drops 
> below a certain threshold (-60 dB maybe). A simple way to deal with this is 
> to just let all voices run all the time.
> 
> - Also, please implement the "all notes off" (123) and "all sounds off" (120) 
> controllers. This really needs to be done at the voice allocation level. 
> Otherwise you invariably end up with hanging notes galore, which is 
> especially annoying if there's no voice stealing. :) I found that some MIDI 
> players (like Drumstick on Linux) are just lazy and will send CC 120/123 
> instead of proper note-offs when some notes are still on when the user 
> presses the stop button. The usual "Panic" button to do the all notes/sounds 
> off action manually in FaustLive would also be helpful.

Sure… the polyphonic mode *is* basic…  (I was sure you would say that ((-;)  It 
was initially developed by Romain/Yann on Android and my job was only to 
cleanup the code a bit and connect to the MIDI stuff.

I've already looked at your faust-lv2 code: the point is: do you think we could 
share a common code base for polyphonic instruments, to be used by faust-vst, 
faust-lv2, this new standalone mode.. etc. ? This would save some 
development/maintenance time. If yes how do you think we should proceed?

> 
> Finally, it's nice to be able to see all the parameters for each voice in 
> FaustLive and manipulate them separately. But there should be a "Lock" button 
> which binds together all the "global" synth parameters (i.e., all parameters 
> except freq, gain and gate) so that you can change stuff like filter 
> resonances or ADSR params for all voices simultaneously (which is the usual 
> way to operate a synth, so "Lock" should probably be checked by default).

Yes also : Yann did the same remark.
> 
> I hope that my nitpicking above doesn't sound too negative. In any case being 
> able to run FaustLive as an instrument is just awesome! A big thank you for 
> that! :)
> 
> Cheers,
> Albert


No problem, thanks Albert for the long feedback… ((-;  

Stéphane 




------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Site24x7 APM Insight: Get Deep Visibility into Application Performance
APM + Mobile APM + RUM: Monitor 3 App instances at just $35/Month
Monitor end-to-end web transactions and take corrective actions now
Troubleshoot faster and improve end-user experience. Signup Now!
http://pubads.g.doubleclick.net/gampad/clk?id=272487151&iu=/4140
_______________________________________________
Faudiostream-devel mailing list
Faudiostream-devel@lists.sourceforge.net
https://lists.sourceforge.net/lists/listinfo/faudiostream-devel

Reply via email to